Suppr超能文献

在新冠疫情前夕,意大利医护人员对新冠病毒感染存在不当的风险认知。

Inappropriate risk perception for SARS-CoV-2 infection among Italian HCWs in the eve of COVID-19 pandemic.

作者信息

Riccò Matteo, Vezzosi Luigi, Balzarini Federica, Bragazzi Nicola Luigi

机构信息

Azienda USL di Reggio EmiliaV.le Amendola n.2 - 42122 REServizio di Prevenzione e Sicurezza negli Ambienti di Lavoro (SPSAL)Dip. di Prevenzione.

Agenzia di Tutela della Salute (ATS) della Val Padana; Via Toscani n.1; Mantova (MN), Italy.

出版信息

Acta Biomed. 2020 May 14;91(3):e2020040. doi: 10.23750/abm.v91i3.9727.

Abstract

Sir, Italy has been recently involved in the outbreak of severe interstitial pneumonia associated with the previously unknown Coronavirus SARS-CoV-2 (1,2). Even before the notification of the first autochthonous cases, the SARS-CoV-2 associated syndrome (COVID-19) had raised an intense attention in the public opinion (3), with a counterproductive over-abundance of mixed quality information. As even Italian healthcare workers (HCWs) were not spared by subsequent misunderstandings and knowledge gaps during the previous influenza pandemic of 2009 (4), we performed a web-based survey (Google® Modules), specifically aimed to characterize knowledge status and risk perceptions in a sample from participating to 6 Facebook discussion groups (181,684 total unique members at the time of the study). The questionnaire was made available between February 1st and 7th, 2020, i.e. around 2 weeks before the first COVID-19 was officially diagnosed in Italian residents.   Overall, the sampled population included 2106 respondents (Table 1), and 39.3% were HCWs. Even though HCWs were more likely to exhibit a better understanding of SARS-CoV-2/COVID-19 related issues (aOR 2.195, 95%CI 1.809 to 2.664), they were not exempt for misunderstandings, particularly on actual incidence and lethality of COVID-19. Interestingly, most of respondents were aware of the main clinical features of COVID-19, with HCWs more frequently acknowledging that the COVID-19 may run pauci- or even asymptomatic (86.3% vs. 79.1%), resembling an Influenza-Like Illness (i.e. fever, cough, headache, etc.), with a potential latency up to 14 days (85·9% vs· 80·3%), eventually spreading by droplets (98.5% vs. 92.7%) rather through running water (92.3% vs· 79.8%), or blood/body fluids (88.0% vs. 70.4%).   Retrospectively, the assessment of preventive measures and risk perception appears somewhat worrisome. For instance, while HCWs were more likely to acknowledge as an appropriate preventive measure wearing a filtering mask (i.e. N95/FFP2/3 mask; aOR 2.296, 95%CI 1.507 to 3.946), around ¼ of HCWs failed to recognize the importance of such personal protective equipment, while 7.4% felt as appropriate the wearing of a surgical mask. Moreover, not only COVID-19 was appropriately acknowledged as a severe disease by only 62.0% of respondents, with no differences between HCWs and non-HCWs, but an even smaller share (i.e. 8.0%) reported any concern for being infected by SARS-CoV-2 in Italy. In fact, at the time of the survey SARS-CoV-2 was more properly associated with international travelers (26.7%).   Our results are therefore of certain interests for several reasons. First at all, early epidemiological reports on the Italian cases of COVID-19 hint towards some failures in the initial management of incident cases (5-6). In fact, in our survey a large share of respondents substantially overlooked the risk to interact with SARS-CoV-2 positive subjects, that was otherwise perceived as a not-so-severe disease (i.e. "nothing more than a seasonal flu", as often described in some social media) (7). Moreover, around a 1/3 of HCWs participating to the study presumptively did not use proper personal protective equipment for the airways interacting with possible COVID-19 cases, either underestimating the infection risk or being unable to recognize early symptoms. Actually, the base of evidence shared by participants at the time of the study substantially ignored that COVID-19 may be characterized by dermatologic and gastro-intestinal symptoms (8-9). As most of infections may be actually pauci- or asymptomatic, such early exposure in the healthcare settings may have contributed to the quick spreading of SARS-CoV-2 epidemic in Northern Italy.   Therefore, despite the intrinsic limits of a convenience sampling, web-based survey (10), our study stresses the importance to improve the overall quality of information on COVID-19 conveyed not only in HCWs, but also in the general population. Moreover, our data may contribute to clarify the early stages of SARS-CoV-2 pandemic in Italy.

摘要

先生,意大利最近卷入了与此前未知的冠状病毒SARS-CoV-2相关的严重间质性肺炎疫情(1,2)。甚至在首例本土病例通报之前,与SARS-CoV-2相关的综合征(COVID-19)就已在公众舆论中引起了强烈关注(3),出现了大量质量参差不齐且适得其反的信息。由于在2009年之前的流感大流行期间,意大利医护人员(HCWs)也未能幸免后续的误解和知识空白(4),我们开展了一项基于网络的调查(谷歌®模块),专门旨在描述参与6个脸书讨论组的样本(研究时共有181,684名独立成员)的知识状况和风险认知。问卷于2020年2月1日至7日发放,即在意大利用于正式确诊首例COVID-19病例前约两周。

总体而言,抽样人群包括2106名受访者(表1),其中39.3%为医护人员。尽管医护人员更有可能对SARS-CoV-2/COVID-19相关问题表现出更好的理解(调整后比值比2.195,95%置信区间1.809至2.664),但他们也难免存在误解,尤其是在COVID-19的实际发病率和致死率方面。有趣的是,大多数受访者了解COVID-19的主要临床特征,医护人员更频繁地认识到COVID-19可能表现为轻微症状甚至无症状(86.3%对79.1%),类似流感样疾病(即发热、咳嗽、头痛等),潜在潜伏期长达14天(85.9%对80.3%),最终通过飞沫传播(98.5%对92.7%)而非通过流水(92.3%对79.8%)或血液/体液传播(88.0%对70.4%)。

回顾来看,对预防措施和风险认知的评估显得有些令人担忧。例如,虽然医护人员更有可能认可佩戴过滤口罩(即N95/FFP2/3口罩)是一种适当的预防措施(调整后比值比2.296,95%置信区间1.507至3.946),但约四分之一医护人员未认识到此类个人防护设备的重要性,而7.4%的人认为佩戴外科口罩是合适的。此外,只有62.0%的受访者正确认识到COVID-19是一种严重疾病,医护人员和非医护人员之间没有差异,甚至更小比例(即8.0%)的人表示担心在意大利感染SARS-CoV-2。事实上,在调查时,SARS-CoV-2更常与国际旅行者相关联(26.7%)。

因此,我们的结果因多种原因具有一定意义。首先,关于意大利COVID-19病例的早期流行病学报告暗示了在初始病例管理方面存在一些失误(5 - 6)。事实上,在我们的调查中,很大一部分受访者基本上忽略了与SARS-CoV-2阳性患者接触的风险,而这种疾病在其他方面被视为不太严重的疾病(即如一些社交媒体中常描述的“不过是季节性流感”)(7)。此外,参与研究的约三分之一医护人员在与可能的COVID-19病例进行气道交互时可能未使用适当的个人防护设备,要么低估了感染风险,要么无法识别早期症状。实际上,研究时参与者所共享的证据基础基本上忽略了COVID-19可能具有皮肤和胃肠道症状(8 - 9)。由于大多数感染实际上可能是轻微症状或无症状,这种在医疗环境中的早期接触可能导致了SARS-CoV-2在意大利北部的快速传播。

因此,尽管便利抽样的基于网络的调查存在固有局限性(10),我们的研究强调了提高不仅向医护人员,而且向普通人群传达的关于COVID-19信息的整体质量的重要性。此外,我们的数据可能有助于阐明意大利SARS-CoV-2大流行的早期阶段。

https://cdn.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/blobs/c4a0/7717016/5350f8fa4185/ACTA-91-40-g001.jpg

文献检索

告别复杂PubMed语法,用中文像聊天一样搜索,搜遍4000万医学文献。AI智能推荐,让科研检索更轻松。

立即免费搜索

文件翻译

保留排版,准确专业,支持PDF/Word/PPT等文件格式,支持 12+语言互译。

免费翻译文档

深度研究

AI帮你快速写综述,25分钟生成高质量综述,智能提取关键信息,辅助科研写作。

立即免费体验