Department of Diagnostic and Interventional Neuroradiology, University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany.
PLoS One. 2020 Sep 17;15(9):e0238952. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0238952. eCollection 2020.
To meet increasing demands to train neuroendovascular techniques, we developed a dedicated simulator applying individualized three-dimensional intracranial aneurysm models ('HANNES'; Hamburg Anatomic Neurointerventional Endovascular Simulator). We hypothesized that HANNES provides a realistic and reproducible training environment to practice coil embolization and to exemplify disparities between neurointerventionalists, thus objectively benchmarking operators at different levels of experience.
Six physicians with different degrees of neurointerventional procedural experience were recruited into a standardized training protocol comprising catheterization of two internal carotid artery (ICA) aneurysms and one basilar tip aneurysm, followed by introduction of one framing coil into each aneurysm and finally complete coil embolization of one determined ICA aneurysm. The level of difficulty increased with every aneurysm. Fluoroscopy was recorded and assessed for procedural characteristics and adverse events.
Physicians were divided into inexperienced and experienced operators, depending on their experience with microcatheter handling. Mean overall catheterization times increased with difficulty of the aneurysm model. Inexperienced operators showed longer catheterization times (median; IQR: 47; 30-84s) than experienced operators (21; 13-58s, p = 0.011) and became significantly faster during the course of the attempts (rho = -0.493, p = 0.009) than the experienced physicians (rho = -0.318, p = 0.106). Number of dangerous maneuvers throughout all attempts was significantly higher for inexperienced operators (median; IQR: 1.0; 0.0-1.5) as compared to experienced operators (0.0; 0.0-1.0, p = 0.014).
HANNES represents a modular neurointerventional training environment for practicing aneurysm coil embolization in vitro. Objective procedural metrics correlate with operator experience, suggesting that the system could be useful for assessing operator proficiency.
为了满足日益增长的神经血管技术培训需求,我们开发了一种专用模拟器,应用个体化三维颅内动脉瘤模型(“HANNES”;汉堡解剖神经介入血管内模拟器)。我们假设 HANNES 提供了一个真实且可重复的培训环境,用于练习线圈栓塞,并举例说明神经介入医师之间的差异,从而客观地对不同经验水平的操作人员进行基准测试。
招募了 6 名具有不同神经介入手术经验程度的医生,参与标准化培训方案,包括对两个颈内动脉(ICA)动脉瘤和一个基底尖动脉瘤进行导管插入,然后在每个动脉瘤中引入一个框架线圈,最后对一个确定的 ICA 动脉瘤进行完全线圈栓塞。每个动脉瘤的难度逐渐增加。记录透视图像并评估手术特点和不良事件。
根据微导管操作经验,医生分为无经验和有经验操作人员。总的导管插入时间随着动脉瘤模型难度的增加而增加。无经验操作人员的导管插入时间(中位数;IQR:47;30-84s)长于有经验操作人员(21;13-58s,p=0.011),并且在尝试过程中明显变快(rho=-0.493,p=0.009),而有经验的医生(rho=-0.318,p=0.106)则较慢。无经验操作人员在所有尝试中危险操作的次数明显更高(中位数;IQR:1.0;0.0-1.5),而有经验的操作人员则较少(0.0;0.0-1.0,p=0.014)。
HANNES 是一种模块化的神经介入培训环境,用于在体外进行动脉瘤线圈栓塞的实践。客观的手术指标与操作人员的经验相关,表明该系统可能有助于评估操作人员的熟练程度。