Hanselman Paul
University of California, Irvine.
Sociol Q. 2019;60(3):498-534. doi: 10.1080/00380253.2019.1625732. Epub 2019 Jul 9.
This paper provides detailed description of students' access to one critical educational resource, teachers that effectively promote learning. Using large scale administrative data from North Carolina in grades 3-8 and value-added measures of effectiveness, I find disadvantages for poor, American Indian, African American, and Hispanic students, but disparities represent less than 2% of observed achievement gaps. Gaps are driven by differential risks of exposure to especially ineffective teachers, which occur between and within schools. The distribution of teacher-related learning opportunities therefore highlights White and higher SES students' advantaged access to important educational resources as well as apparent limits to those advantages.
本文详细描述了学生获取一种关键教育资源的情况,即能有效促进学习的教师。利用北卡罗来纳州3至8年级的大规模行政数据以及教师有效性的增值衡量指标,我发现贫困学生、美国印第安学生、非裔美国学生和西班牙裔学生处于劣势,但这些差距在观察到的成绩差距中所占比例不到2%。差距是由接触特别低效教师的不同风险导致的,这种情况在学校之间和学校内部都存在。因此,与教师相关的学习机会分布凸显了白人学生和社会经济地位较高学生在获取重要教育资源方面的优势,以及这些优势的明显局限性。