Clinic for Ruminants with Ambulatory and Herd Health Services at the Centre for Clinical Veterinary Medicine, LMU Munich, Oberschleissheim, Germany
Clinic for Ruminants with Ambulatory and Herd Health Services at the Centre for Clinical Veterinary Medicine, LMU Munich, Oberschleissheim, Germany.
Vet Rec. 2020 Nov 14;187(10):e90. doi: 10.1136/vr.105920. Epub 2020 Sep 23.
Pain recognition in cattle is difficult, but the control and treatment of pain are essential for animal welfare. Pain evaluation depends on the observer's experience and opinion, resulting in different approaches towards pain and the use of analgesics.
A questionnaire to assess the attitudes of veterinarians towards pain and pain management in cattle was sent to 1097 bovine practitioners in Bavaria. Out of 287 returned questionnaires, 274 could be analysed.
Claw amputation, extirpation of the eye bulb and caesarean section were considered to be the most painful procedures in adult cattle, and castration, umbilical surgery and laparotomy in calves. Orthopaedic diseases like bone fractures or arthritis were estimated to be the most painful conditions in both cattle and calves, and ileus and meningitis in calves. Female veterinarians scored pain higher than their male colleagues. Even though 75.5 per cent of veterinarians stated that they used analgesics adequately, pain management during surgery was low, especially for castration and dehorning in calves.
Bavarian bovine veterinarians differ in their opinions about pain in cattle and the results of this study indicate that there a mismatch between their use of analgesics and the pain scores they awarded.
牛只的疼痛识别较为困难,但控制和治疗疼痛对动物福利至关重要。疼痛评估取决于观察者的经验和意见,导致了对疼痛和使用镇痛药的不同方法。
向巴伐利亚州的 1097 名牛科兽医发送了一份评估兽医对牛只疼痛和疼痛管理态度的问卷。在 287 份返回的问卷中,有 274 份可以进行分析。
断趾、眼球摘除和剖腹产被认为是成年牛最痛苦的手术,而去势、脐部手术和剖腹术则是小牛最痛苦的手术。骨科疾病,如骨折或关节炎,被估计在牛和小牛中都是最痛苦的情况,而小牛则是肠梗和脑膜炎。女兽医比男兽医对疼痛的评分更高。尽管 75.5%的兽医表示他们使用了足够的镇痛药,但手术期间的疼痛管理水平较低,尤其是在小牛的去势和去角手术中。
巴伐利亚州的牛科兽医对牛只的疼痛有不同的看法,本研究的结果表明,他们使用镇痛药和疼痛评分之间存在不匹配。