Department of Neurology, San Antonio Military Medical Center, 3551 Roger Brooke Drive, Fort Sam Houston, TX 78234.
Defense and Veterans Brain Injury Center, San Antonio Military Medical Center, 3551 Roger Brooke Drive, Fort Sam Houston, TX 78234.
Mil Med. 2020 Mar 2;185(3-4):377-384. doi: 10.1093/milmed/usz292.
Epigenetics can serve as a marker of susceptibility to many known psychiatric diseases. DNA methylation patterns of multiple genes have been studied in both civilian populations and military personnel with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Many of these genes serve various functions that span the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, immune system, and central nervous system (CNS) growth factors and neurotransmission. It is thought that the methylation levels of such genes may be able to identify individuals who are at higher risk of developing PTSD. Our study seeks to establish whether previously reported PTSD genes possess a particular methylation pattern that is predictive of PTSD in active duty military members with combat exposure.
This is an institutional review board (IRB)-approved, cross-sectional, case control, gene-environment interaction study. About 170 active military members with and without PTSD were recruited. Patients with a history of structural brain damage, traumatic brain injury (TBI) resulting in loss of consciousness, predeployment diagnosis of PTSD or anxiety disorder, and predeployment prescription of an antidepressant or psychoactive medication were excluded. Validated measures of childhood trauma and adversity (adverse childhood experience [ACE] score), PTSD symptoms (PTSD check-list military version [PCL-M]), and combat exposure scales (CES) were measured via validated questionnaires for all subjects. After extracting DNA from peripheral blood provided by the 170 subjects, we determined methylation percentages, via pyrosequencing assays, for nine target areas within the following seven genes: BDNF, NR3C1, MAN2C1, TLR8, SLC6A4, IL-18, and SKA2. These genes are commonly reported in the literature as being highly correlated with PTSD and early-life traumatic experiences.Methylation levels were measured as a percentage at specific sites within the previously mentioned genes. Data were examined with SPSS v 22.0 Statistics and JMP v13.1 software using a general linear model for methylation × trauma (CES scores) split by diagnosis of PTSD or not, methylation versus childhood trauma (ACE scores), and methylation versus PTSD severity (PCL-M score). Two-way ANOVA was performed to control for antidepressant use. A two-tailed Student t-test was performed for PTSD analyses and was correlated with PTSD diagnosis, demographic information as well as ACE score, PCL-M score, and CES scores.
Differentially methylated sites that were highly associated with PTSD diagnosis were found in three of seven candidate genes: BDNF, NR3C1, and MAN2C1. When compared to controls, patients with PTSD diagnosis had significantly lower levels of methylation, even after controlling for antidepressant use. PCL-M, ACE, and CES scores were significantly associated with PTSD diagnosis.
Our study suggests that methylation of key genes involved in synaptic plasticity and the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis is associated with lower levels of methylation in military PTSD subjects exposed to combat when compared to their non-PTSD counterparts. Strengths of this study include controlling for antidepressant use and excluding TBI patients. Similar studies in an active duty population of this size are scarce. What is not clear is whether methylation changes are driving PTSD symptomology or whether they are merely a marker of disease. Future areas of research include prospective studies that measure methylation pre- and postcombat exposure in the same individual.
表观遗传学可以作为许多已知精神疾病易感性的标志物。已经研究了多个基因的 DNA 甲基化模式,包括平民人群和患有创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的军事人员。这些基因中的许多基因具有各种功能,涵盖下丘脑-垂体-肾上腺轴、免疫系统和中枢神经系统(CNS)生长因子和神经递质。据认为,这些基因的甲基化水平可能能够识别出更容易患上 PTSD 的个体。我们的研究旨在确定先前报道的 PTSD 基因是否具有特定的甲基化模式,该模式可预测具有战斗暴露的现役军人中的 PTSD。
这是一项机构审查委员会(IRB)批准的、横断面、病例对照、基因-环境相互作用研究。大约 170 名有 PTSD 和无 PTSD 的现役军人被招募。排除了有结构性脑损伤史、导致意识丧失的创伤性脑损伤(TBI)、部署前 PTSD 或焦虑症诊断、以及部署前抗抑郁药或精神药物处方的患者。所有受试者均通过经过验证的儿童创伤和逆境问卷(不良童年经历[ACE]评分)、PTSD 症状(军人版 PTSD 清单[PCL-M])和战斗暴露量表(CES)进行了有效的测量。对 170 名受试者提供的外周血进行 DNA 提取后,我们通过焦磷酸测序测定了以下七个基因中的九个目标区域的甲基化百分比:BDNF、NR3C1、MAN2C1、TLR8、SLC6A4、IL-18 和 SKA2。这些基因在文献中通常被报道与 PTSD 和早期创伤经历高度相关。甲基化水平以特定基因内特定部位的百分比表示。使用 SPSS v 22.0 Statistics 和 JMP v13.1 软件,通过特定的基因甲基化(PCL-M 评分)与 PTSD 严重程度(PCL-M 评分)进行分析,通过诊断为 PTSD 或非 PTSD、甲基化与儿童创伤(ACE 评分)进行分析。采用一般线性模型,使用双尾学生 t 检验进行 PTSD 分析,并与 PTSD 诊断、人口统计学信息以及 ACE 评分、PCL-M 评分和 CES 评分相关。进行了双因素方差分析以控制抗抑郁药的使用。进行了双尾学生 t 检验进行 PTSD 分析,并与 PTSD 诊断、人口统计学信息以及 ACE 评分、PCL-M 评分和 CES 评分相关。进行了双因素方差分析以控制抗抑郁药的使用。进行了双尾学生 t 检验进行 PTSD 分析,并与 PTSD 诊断、人口统计学信息以及 ACE 评分、PCL-M 评分和 CES 评分相关。进行了双因素方差分析以控制抗抑郁药的使用。
在七个候选基因中的三个基因中发现了与 PTSD 诊断高度相关的差异甲基化位点:BDNF、NR3C1 和 MAN2C1。与对照组相比,即使在控制了抗抑郁药的使用后,患有 PTSD 诊断的患者的甲基化水平也明显较低。PCL-M、ACE 和 CES 评分与 PTSD 诊断显著相关。
我们的研究表明,与突触可塑性和下丘脑-垂体-肾上腺轴相关的关键基因的甲基化与暴露于战斗的 PTSD 军人的甲基化水平较低有关,而与 PTSD 对照相比。这项研究的优势包括控制抗抑郁药的使用和排除 TBI 患者。在这种大小的现役人群中进行类似的研究很少。目前尚不清楚的是,甲基化变化是导致 PTSD 症状的原因,还是仅仅是疾病的标志物。未来的研究领域包括在同一个体中前瞻性地测量战斗前和战斗后的甲基化。