Oke Adekunle, Osobajo Oluyomi, Obi Lovelin, Omotayo Temitope
Aberdeen Business School, Robert Gordon University, Garthdee Road, Aberdeen AB10 7QE, UK.
School of Architecture and the Built Environment, University of Wolverhampton, Wulfruna Street, Wolverhampton WV1 1LY, UK.
Waste Manag. 2020 Dec;118:463-470. doi: 10.1016/j.wasman.2020.09.008. Epub 2020 Sep 23.
Packaging waste production, especially single-use containers, is exerting detrimental effects on terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems, including human health. To internalise the externalities associated with single-use containers, different instruments, including a deposit refund scheme (DRS), have been operationalised in many countries. Therefore, DRS is introduced in Scotland to reduce plastic litters by increasing recycling rates and incentivising pro-environmental behavioural change. This study addresses the complexity of single-use plastic containers by analysing consumers' perceptions regarding the introduction of DRS in Scotland. Using 940 comments from the BBC "Have Your Say" messageboard, this study adopts sentiment analysis to understand consumers' opinions about the introduction and implementation of DRS in Scotland. Findings suggest that a UK-wide scheme that is similar in terms of operations and structure is required for DRS to be successful. While consumers' knowledge and opinions about DRS are mixed, the efficacy of DRS including its relevance is questioned and raises doubts about its contribution to sustainability. The findings imply the need for UK countries to negotiate and collaborate on appropriate and attractive interventions in addressing post-consumer single-use plastic containers. The implications of the findings for policy and practice, especially in improving the operations of DRS are further discussed.
包装废弃物的产生,尤其是一次性容器,正在对陆地和水生生态系统,包括人类健康产生有害影响。为了将与一次性容器相关的外部性内部化,包括押金退还计划(DRS)在内的不同手段已在许多国家实施。因此,苏格兰引入了押金退还计划,以通过提高回收率和激励有利于环境的行为改变来减少塑料垃圾。本研究通过分析消费者对苏格兰引入押金退还计划的看法,探讨一次性塑料容器的复杂性。本研究利用英国广播公司“表达你的意见”留言板上的940条评论,采用情感分析来了解消费者对苏格兰押金退还计划的引入和实施的看法。研究结果表明,要使押金退还计划取得成功,需要一个在运作和结构方面类似的全英国范围的计划。虽然消费者对押金退还计划的了解和看法不一,但押金退还计划的有效性,包括其相关性受到质疑,并对其对可持续性的贡献产生怀疑。研究结果意味着英国各地区需要就解决消费后一次性塑料容器问题的适当且有吸引力的干预措施进行谈判与合作。进一步讨论了研究结果对政策和实践的影响,特别是在改善押金退还计划的运作方面。