Department of Prosthodontics, University of Iowa College of Dentistry, Iowa City, Iowa, USA.
Pediatric Dentistry, University of Iowa College of Dentistry, Iowa City, Iowa, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2021 Mar;85(3):379-382. doi: 10.1002/jdd.12443. Epub 2020 Sep 29.
A comparison of student learning in a critical thinking exercise for technology decision-making occurred with the onset of coronavirus and the switch from face-to-face to distance with Zoom. Literature on explicit critical thinking skill sets is scant in any format, including distance learning. While face-to-face and Zoom have similarities, seizing this opportunity for comparison can set the stage to determine soundness of distance learning in critical thinking on a preliminary basis. The learning outcome, learning guide and assessment instrument remained the same for the exercise in both formats; student teams presented analyses of different technologies with assessment by 2 faculty as before. Forty students had not completed the exercise when the coronavirus shut down occurred. Students performed at as high a level using virtual/Zoom as with face-to-face.
在冠状病毒爆发期间,我们将技术决策的批判性思维练习从面对面教学切换到了远程的 Zoom 教学。在任何形式的学习中,包括远程学习,都很少有关于明确批判性思维技能的文献。虽然面对面教学和 Zoom 教学有一些相似之处,但我们可以利用这次比较的机会,初步确定远程学习在批判性思维方面的合理性。在这两种模式下,练习的学习成果、学习指南和评估工具保持不变;学生团队以前一样使用 2 位教师进行评估,对不同技术进行分析。当冠状病毒关闭时,有 40 名学生没有完成练习。学生在虚拟/Zoom 环境下的表现与面对面教学时一样出色。