Department of Neurosurgery, The Clinical Medical College of Yangzhou University, Yangzhou University, Yangzhou 225009, China.
Nursing School of Yangzhou University, Yangzhou University, Yangzhou 225009, China.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Sep 27;17(19):7070. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17197070.
Outpatient care is made up of medical procedures, tests, and services that can be provided to the patient in a setting that doesn't involve an overnight hospital stay. In China, tertiary hospitals are medical services centers of health care systems, and some tertiary hospitals had more than 20,000 outpatient visits per day. However, a systematic review of existed evidence on factors influencing the outpatient satisfaction in tertiary hospitals in China could inform the efforts and does not yet exist. Therefore, in order to better understand the outpatient satisfaction provided by tertiary hospitals in China, we carried out a systematic review following PRISMA guidelines. Studies reporting on the level of and factors associated with outpatient satisfaction in Chinese tertiary hospitals were systematically searched in both Chinese and English electronic databases. A total of 36 articles reported 35 studies that met the inclusion criteria. Out of these eight were household surveys covering 12,119 residents, and another 27 directly interviewed 45,930 outpatients during their hospital visits from 185 hospitals. The included studies generally used self-designed questionnaire and indicated there is a lack of standardized questionnaire for investigating outpatient satisfaction in China. The outpatients showed the highest satisfaction with the doctors and nurses and the lowest satisfaction with the hospital hygiene and outpatient procedures, especially with the long waiting time. The socio-demographic characteristics (e.g., age, marital status, income and education levels), professional skills and service attitudes of medical staff were reported to be associated with outpatient satisfaction. The results indicated that in China, the outpatient satisfaction can be largely improved. Firstly, the attitude of medical service providers, especially the pre-diagnosis nurses, registration officers, and pharmaceutical counters should be improved. Furthermore, to shorten the waiting time, policies should be developed to guide patients with common diseases and slight discomforts to community health systems to alleviate the overload in tertiary hospitals. Considering the strained relations between the doctors and patients in the clinical practice, improving patient satisfaction in China deserves more attention and research.
门诊医疗服务包括可在不涉及住院过夜的环境中向患者提供的医疗程序、检查和服务。在中国,三级医院是医疗保健系统的医疗服务中心,一些三级医院每天的门诊就诊量超过 20000 人次。然而,系统综述现有的关于影响中国三级医院门诊满意度的因素的证据可以为努力提供信息,但目前还不存在。因此,为了更好地了解中国三级医院提供的门诊满意度,我们按照 PRISMA 指南进行了系统综述。系统地检索了中文和英文电子数据库中关于中国三级医院门诊满意度水平及其相关因素的研究。共有 36 篇文章报道了符合纳入标准的 35 项研究。其中 8 项为家庭调查,涵盖了 12119 名居民,另有 27 项直接在 185 家医院对 45930 名门诊患者进行了医院就诊期间的访谈。纳入的研究通常使用自行设计的问卷,表明中国缺乏用于调查门诊满意度的标准化问卷。门诊患者对医生和护士的满意度最高,对医院卫生和门诊流程的满意度最低,尤其是对长时间的等待时间。社会人口统计学特征(如年龄、婚姻状况、收入和教育水平)、医护人员的专业技能和服务态度与门诊满意度相关。结果表明,在中国,门诊满意度可以在很大程度上得到提高。首先,医疗服务提供者的态度,特别是预诊护士、挂号员和配药师的态度,应该得到改善。此外,为了缩短等待时间,应制定政策,引导患有常见疾病和轻微不适的患者前往社区卫生系统就诊,以缓解三级医院的超负荷运转。考虑到临床实践中医生和患者之间紧张的关系,提高中国患者的满意度值得更多关注和研究。