Yamaguchi Sayaka, Okutsu Mitsuyoshi, Tomori Kounosuke, Nagayama Hirofumi, Okita Yuho
Nonprofit Organization Hablis, Gifu, Japan.
Department of Occupational Therapy, School of Health Science, Tokyo University of Technology, Tokyo, Japan.
Aust Occup Ther J. 2021 Apr;68(2):135-143. doi: 10.1111/1440-1630.12703. Epub 2020 Sep 30.
This pilot study examined the effect of collaborative consultation with teachers in school-based occupational therapy (SBOT) using iPad application for goal-setting-Aid for Decision-Making in Occupation Choice for School (ADOC-S).
A single arm pre-post intervention design was conducted at four preschools in Japan. The participants were 10 preschool teachers (10.5 ± 0.4 years of teaching), and 10 children (3.8 ± 0.4 years old; five boys). The teachers received three collaborative consultations (1 hr for each) from one occupational therapist. Firstly, the occupational therapist conducted an observational assessment of the child's school life, then the teacher and occupational therapist identified occupation-based goals for each child using the ADOC-S. Secondly, the teacher and the occupational therapist developed the graded goals using the Goal Attainment Scale (GAS) and discussed the daily intervention plan for the teachers to conduct. Thirdly, the occupational therapist followed up on the intervention process using GAS. The subjective outcome was measured at 10 point-satisfaction and performance score in each goal using Canadian Occupational Performance Measure (COPM). The observed outcome was measured using GAS and Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ).
All the participants including teachers and children successfully underwent the intervention process. Significant improvement was found pre-post and effect size (ES) was large on the COPM (ES; r = .85-.94), GAS (ES; r = .98-.99) and SDQ (ES; r = .64). All goals (30/30) exceeded expectations of GAS from zero to +2.
Although there are some limitations and considerations which need to be resolved for future studies, our results suggest that ADOC-S would help build a rapport with a teacher in SBOT settings, and this collaborative consultation would facilitate a positive outcome.
本试点研究探讨了在基于学校的职业治疗(SBOT)中,通过使用iPad应用程序“学校职业选择决策辅助目标设定工具(ADOC-S)”与教师进行协作咨询的效果。
在日本的四所幼儿园进行了单组前后干预设计。参与者包括10名幼儿园教师(教龄10.5±0.4年)和10名儿童(3.8±0.4岁;5名男孩)。教师接受了一名职业治疗师进行的三次协作咨询(每次1小时)。首先,职业治疗师对儿童的学校生活进行观察评估,然后教师和职业治疗师使用ADOC-S为每个儿童确定基于职业的目标。其次,教师和职业治疗师使用目标达成量表(GAS)制定分级目标,并讨论教师进行的日常干预计划。第三,职业治疗师使用GAS对干预过程进行跟进。主观结果通过加拿大职业表现测量量表(COPM)在每个目标的10分满意度和表现得分上进行测量。观察到的结果通过GAS和长处与困难问卷(SDQ)进行测量。
包括教师和儿童在内的所有参与者都成功完成了干预过程。在COPM(效应量;r = 0.85 - 0.94)、GAS(效应量;r = 0.98 - 0.99)和SDQ(效应量;r = 0.64)上,前后对比有显著改善,且效应量较大。所有目标(30/30)均超出了GAS从0到+2的预期。
尽管未来研究还存在一些需要解决的局限性和注意事项,但我们的结果表明,ADOC-S有助于在SBOT环境中与教师建立融洽关系,这种协作咨询将促进产生积极的结果。