Goetz C G, Tanner C M, Wilson R S, Carroll V S, Como P G, Shannon K M
Ann Neurol. 1987 Mar;21(3):307-10. doi: 10.1002/ana.410210313.
Clonidine has been suggested to be effective in Gilles de la Tourette's syndrome (GTS), but no double-blind study has ever evaluated its effects using objective measures. Thirty patients with GTS completed a 6-month placebo-controlled crossover study of the effectiveness of clonidine. Videotapes were obtained at each 3-week visit and were evaluated randomly at the end of the study for distribution, frequency, and severity of motor and vocal tics. Quantifiable psychometric examinations were performed as well. The use of clonidine did not significantly (p less than 0.05) reduce motor tics, vocalizations, or behavior. The effect of a low dose (0.0075 mg/kg/day) was no different from that of a high dose (0.015 mg/kg/day); children's responses were no different from adults'; and those also receiving neuroleptic agents showed the same lack of efficacy as seen in patients on no other medication. Dosing schedule did not affect the objective ratings; scores from clonidine given twice a day were equivalent to those for three times a day.
有人提出可乐定对抽动秽语综合征(GTS)有效,但尚无双盲研究使用客观指标评估其效果。30例GTS患者完成了一项为期6个月的关于可乐定有效性的安慰剂对照交叉研究。在每3周的访视时获取录像带,并在研究结束时随机评估运动性和发声性抽动的分布、频率及严重程度。同时也进行了可量化的心理测评。使用可乐定并未显著(p<0.05)减少运动性抽动、发声或行为。低剂量(0.0075mg/kg/天)与高剂量(0.015mg/kg/天)的效果无差异;儿童的反应与成人无异;同时接受抗精神病药物治疗的患者与未服用其他药物的患者一样缺乏疗效。给药方案不影响客观评分;每日两次给予可乐定的评分与每日三次给药的评分相当。