Mammen Oommen, Tew James, Painter Tiffany, Bettinelli Elizabeth, Beckjord Jennifer
University of Pittsburgh, United States of America; University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, United States of America.
University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, United States of America.
Gen Hosp Psychiatry. 2020 Nov-Dec;67:51-57. doi: 10.1016/j.genhosppsych.2020.08.014. Epub 2020 Sep 6.
The distinction between acute and chronic suicidality is important, because interventions designed to address acute suicidality can worsen chronic suicidality, resulting in an escalating cycle of suicide threats, suicide attempts, and futile hospitalizations. Though most chronically suicidal borderline personality disorder patients improve and do not complete suicide, the potential for suicide contributes to these hospitalizations and a paucity of outpatient services due to treaters' concern over malpractice lawsuits in case of suicide. Communicating with patients' families about the suicide risk has been suggested as a means to mitigate this malpractice risk, but the approach to such communication has not been described.
Once chronic suicidality is identified, a stepwise approach to communicating with the patient's family is described.
The potential benefits of this risk communication are described, for patients, families, treaters, healthcare systems, and health and malpractice insurers.
It helps to develop an alliance with families and patients around a shared understanding of outcomes in chronic suicidality - most eventually do better, but the risk of completed suicide is real. This enables patients and families to make a more fully informed choice about treatment, which in turn can reduce litigation risk in the minority of cases where the patient completes suicide.
区分急性自杀倾向和慢性自杀倾向很重要,因为旨在应对急性自杀倾向的干预措施可能会使慢性自杀倾向恶化,从而导致自杀威胁、自杀未遂和徒劳住院的恶性循环。尽管大多数有慢性自杀倾向的边缘型人格障碍患者病情会改善且不会自杀身亡,但自杀的可能性导致了这些住院情况,以及由于治疗者担心自杀情况下的医疗事故诉讼而导致门诊服务匮乏。有人建议与患者家属沟通自杀风险是降低这种医疗事故风险的一种方式,但尚未描述这种沟通的方法。
一旦确定为慢性自杀倾向,将描述与患者家属沟通的逐步方法。
阐述了这种风险沟通对患者、家属、治疗者、医疗系统以及健康和医疗事故保险公司的潜在益处。
围绕对慢性自杀倾向结果的共同理解,与家属和患者建立联盟会有帮助——大多数人最终情况会好转,但自杀身亡的风险是真实存在的。这能使患者和家属在治疗方面做出更充分知情的选择,进而在少数患者自杀身亡的案例中降低诉讼风险。