Mahmarian J J, Verani M S, Hohmann T, Hill R, Thornton B C, Bolli R, Young J B, Roberts R, Pratt C M
Circulation. 1987 Aug;76(2):324-31. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.76.2.324.
This placebo-controlled, double-blind trial compared the hemodynamic effects of sotalol and quinidine with the use of rest and exercise gated radionuclide angiography. Patients had frequent ventricular premature depolarizations (greater than or equal to 30 VPDs/hour) and depressed cardiac function (mean ejection fraction 43 +/- 15%). Resting left ventricular ejection fraction and stroke volume index increased (p less than .002, p less than .001, respectively) during sotalol therapy, associated with a concomitant fall in heart rate (p less than .001). Quinidine also increased mean left ventricular ejection fraction, but less so than did sotalol (p less than .05). Quinidine significantly decreased left ventricular end-diastolic (p less than .05) and end-systolic (p less than .002) volumes, but had no effect on stroke volume index or heart rate. Neither drug affected cardiac index. Quinidine resulted in no symptomatic deterioration in left ventricular function or serious arrhythmia aggravation. In contrast, five patients on sotalol developed either decompensated congestive heart failure (two patients), arrhythmia aggravation (two patients), or hypotension associated with bradyarrhythmia (one patient). These patients had a unique hemodynamic profile that can be used to identify patients likely to have a poor outcome on sotalol. This profile reflected a lack of cardiac reserve, characterized by an inability to increase stroke volume and cardiac output with supine bicycle exercise.
这项安慰剂对照、双盲试验采用静息和运动门控放射性核素血管造影术比较了索他洛尔和奎尼丁的血流动力学效应。患者有频发室性早搏(每小时≥30次室性早搏)且心功能减退(平均射血分数43±15%)。在索他洛尔治疗期间,静息左心室射血分数和每搏量指数增加(分别为p<0.002,p<0.001),同时心率下降(p<0.001)。奎尼丁也使平均左心室射血分数增加,但幅度小于索他洛尔(p<0.05)。奎尼丁显著降低左心室舒张末期(p<0.05)和收缩末期(p<0.002)容积,但对每搏量指数或心率无影响。两种药物均不影响心脏指数。奎尼丁未导致左心室功能出现症状性恶化或严重心律失常加重。相比之下,5例服用索他洛尔的患者出现了失代偿性充血性心力衰竭(2例)、心律失常加重(2例)或与缓慢性心律失常相关的低血压(1例)。这些患者具有独特的血流动力学特征,可用于识别可能对索他洛尔治疗效果不佳的患者。该特征反映了心脏储备不足,其特点是仰卧位自行车运动时无法增加每搏量和心输出量。