Department of Epidemiology and Global Health, Umeå University , Umeå, Sweden.
Center for Clinical Research Dalarna-Uppsala University , Falun, Sweden.
Glob Health Action. 2020 Dec 31;13(1):1819689. doi: 10.1080/16549716.2020.1819689.
Research suggests that social status in school plays an important role in the social lives of adolescents and that their social status is associated with their health. Additional knowledge about adolescents' understanding of social hierarchies could help to explain inequalities in adolescents' health and guide public health interventions.
The study aimed to explore what contributes to subjective social status in school and the strategies used for social positioning.
A qualitative research design with think-aloud interviews was used. The study included 57 adolescents in lower (7 grade) and upper secondary school (12 grade) in Sweden. Subjective social status was explored using a slightly modified version of the MacArthur Scale of Subjective Social Status in school. Data were analyzed using thematic network analysis.
The participants were highly aware of their social status in school. Elements tied to gender, age, ethnicity and parental economy influenced their preconditions in the positioning. In addition, expectations on how to look, act and interact, influenced the pursue for social desirability. The way these different factors intersected and had to be balanced suggests that social positioning in school is complex and multifaceted.
Because the norms that guided social positioning left little room for diversity, the possible negative impact of status hierarchies on adolescents' health needs to be considered. In school interventions, we suggest that norms on e.g. gender and ethnicity need to be addressed and problematized from an intersectional approach.
研究表明,学校中的社会地位对青少年的社交生活起着重要作用,他们的社会地位与他们的健康有关。更多地了解青少年对社会等级的理解,可以帮助解释青少年健康不平等现象,并指导公共卫生干预措施。
本研究旨在探讨哪些因素导致了学校中的主观社会地位,以及用于社会定位的策略。
采用出声思维访谈的定性研究设计。该研究包括瑞典 57 名处于较低年级(7 年级)和较高年级(12 年级)的青少年。使用稍微修改后的麦克阿瑟学校主观社会地位量表来探讨主观社会地位。使用主题网络分析对数据进行分析。
参与者对他们在学校中的社会地位非常敏感。与性别、年龄、族裔和父母经济状况有关的因素影响了他们的定位前提。此外,对如何表现、行动和互动的期望也影响了对社会期望的追求。这些不同因素的交叉和平衡方式表明,学校中的社会定位是复杂和多方面的。
由于指导社会定位的规范几乎没有给多样性留下空间,因此需要考虑地位等级对青少年健康的潜在负面影响。在学校干预中,我们建议需要从交叉的角度解决和质疑有关性别和族裔的规范。