Culha Yeliz, Culha Mehmet Gokhan, Acaroglu Rengin
Fundamentals of Nursing Department, Istanbul University-Cerrahpasa Florence Nightingale Faculty of Nursing, Istanbul, Turkey.
Urology Department, University of Health Sciences, Okmeydani Training and Research Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey.
Int Neurourol J. 2020 Sep;24(3):286-292. doi: 10.5213/inj.2040098.049. Epub 2020 Sep 30.
The aim of this study was to assess the clean intermittent catheterization (CIC) training and education videos on YouTube.
This study was conducted in English language in descriptive type to evaluate the content, reliability, and quality of Internet videos related to CIC training. The search was performed by using term "clean intermittent catheterization" and "intermittent self catheterization" on YouTube in August 2019. The content of the selected videos was analyzed by 2 independent experts in the field. The DISCERN questionnaire was used to analyze the reliability of the video and the global quality score (GQS) was used for the quality of the video.
When the contents of the 64 videos included in the study were examined, it was found that 41 of them contained useful information and 23 of them contained misleading information. DISCERN scores, video coverage scores, and GQS of videos with useful information were found to be statistically higher than those with misleading information (P<0.001). When the sources of the videos were examined, it was seen that 78.05% of the videos containing useful information were published by medical advertisement/for-profit companies (P<0.001). The reliability scores, coverage scores, and GQS of the videos from medical advertisement/for-profit companies were significantly higher than the other sources (P<0.001).
In this study, it was seen that the majority of YouTube CIC training videos examined within the scope of the research were published by medical advertisement/for-profit companies and most of these videos contain useful information.
本研究旨在评估YouTube上的清洁间歇性导尿(CIC)培训及教育视频。
本研究以描述性方式用英语进行,以评估与CIC培训相关的网络视频的内容、可靠性和质量。2019年8月在YouTube上使用“清洁间歇性导尿”和“间歇性自我导尿”这两个术语进行搜索。所选视频的内容由该领域的2名独立专家进行分析。使用DISCERN问卷分析视频的可靠性,使用全球质量评分(GQS)评估视频质量。
在检查纳入研究的64个视频的内容时,发现其中41个包含有用信息,23个包含误导性信息。发现包含有用信息的视频的DISCERN评分、视频覆盖率评分和GQS在统计学上高于包含误导性信息的视频(P<0.001)。在检查视频来源时,发现包含有用信息的视频中有78.05%是由医疗广告/营利性公司发布的(P<0.001)。来自医疗广告/营利性公司的视频的可靠性评分、覆盖率评分和GQS显著高于其他来源(P<0.001)。
在本研究中,发现在研究范围内检查的大多数YouTube CIC培训视频是由医疗广告/营利性公司发布的,并且这些视频中的大多数包含有用信息。