J Sport Rehabil. 2020 Oct 7;30(3):452-457. doi: 10.1123/jsr.2020-0111.
Hamstring muscle tightness is one of the most common problems in athletic and healthy people. Dry needling (DN) was found to be an effective approach for improving muscle flexibility, but there is no study to compare this approach with static stretching (SS) as a common technique for the increase of muscle length.
To compare the immediate effects of DN and SS on hamstring flexibility in healthy subjects with hamstring tightness.
A single-blind randomized controlled trial.
A musculoskeletal physiotherapy clinic at Tehran University of Medical Sciences.
Forty healthy subjects (female: 32, age range: 18-40 y) with hamstring tightness were randomly assigned into 2 groups of DN and SS.
The DN group received a single session of DN on 3 points of the hamstring muscles, each for 1 minute. The SS group received a single session of SS of the hamstrings, consisting of 3 sets of 30-second SS with a 10-second rest between sets in the active knee extension test (AKET) position.
The AKET, muscle compliance, passive peak torque, and stretch tolerance were measured at the baseline, immediately, and 15 minutes after the interventions.
Improvements in all outcomes was better for the DN group than for the SS group. DN increased muscle compliance significantly 15 minutes after the intervention, but it did not improve in the SS group.
DN is effective in improving hamstring flexibility compared with SS. One session of DN can be an effective treatment for hamstring tightness and increase hamstring flexibility. The improvements suggest that DN is a novel treatment for hamstring flexibility.
腘绳肌紧张是运动员和健康人群中最常见的问题之一。干针疗法(DN)被发现是一种提高肌肉柔韧性的有效方法,但尚无研究将其与静态拉伸(SS)作为增加肌肉长度的常用技术进行比较。
比较 DN 和 SS 对有腘绳肌紧张的健康受试者腘绳肌柔韧性的即刻影响。
单盲随机对照试验。
德黑兰医科大学肌肉骨骼物理治疗诊所。
40 名有腘绳肌紧张的健康受试者(女性:32 名,年龄范围:18-40 岁)被随机分为 DN 和 SS 两组。
DN 组在腘绳肌的 3 个点接受单次 DN 治疗,每个点持续 1 分钟。SS 组接受单次 SS 治疗,包括 3 组 30 秒 SS,组间休息 10 秒,在主动膝关节伸展试验(AKET)位置。
在基线、即刻和干预后 15 分钟测量 AKET、肌肉顺应性、被动峰值扭矩和拉伸耐受性。
与 SS 组相比,DN 组所有结果的改善都更好。DN 在干预后 15 分钟时显著增加肌肉顺应性,但 SS 组没有改善。
与 SS 相比,DN 可有效改善腘绳肌柔韧性。单次 DN 治疗可有效治疗腘绳肌紧张并增加腘绳肌柔韧性。这些改善表明 DN 是一种治疗腘绳肌柔韧性的新方法。