Smerilli Gianluca, Cipolletta Edoardo, Tanimura Shun, Di Battista Jacopo, Di Carlo Marco, Carotti Marina, Salaffi Fausto, Grassi Walter, Filippucci Emilio
Rheumatology Unit, Department of Clinical and Molecular Sciences, Polytechnic University of Marche, "Carlo Urbani" Hospital, Via Aldo Moro 25, Jesi, 60035, Ancona, Italy.
Rheumatology Department, Hokkaido Medical Center for Rheumatic Diseases, Sapporo, Japan.
Clin Rheumatol. 2021 Mar;40(3):1055-1060. doi: 10.1007/s10067-020-05440-6. Epub 2020 Oct 11.
Ultrasound (US) is a promising tool for assessing sarcopenia. We aimed to test in the rheumatology setting two US scanning protocols to measure muscle thickness (MT) at the anterior thigh level and to assess their feasibility and reliability. In the first phase of the study, three rheumatologists performed a US examination on 19 consecutive patients adopting two scanning protocols, namely the anterior superior iliac spine (ASIS) and the greater trochanter techniques. After consensus was obtained on the easiest scanning protocol to perform, two rheumatologists adopted only the ASIS technique in 40 consecutive patients. MT measurements were recorded as well as the time needed to complete each scanning protocol bilaterally. The median time needed to complete the US examination was under 5 minutes for each of the two techniques, with no significant difference between them (p = 0.64). In the first phase, we found an excellent inter-observer reliability of the proposed scanning protocols, with a higher but nonstatistically significant intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) for the ASIS technique compared with the greater trochanter technique (ICC 0.97 vs. ICC 0.92, p = 0.05). The ASIS technique had a significantly higher intra-observer reliability (ICC 0.97 vs. ICC 0.92, p < 0.01). In the second phase, the ASIS technique confirmed on a larger sample its excellent inter-observer reliability, with an ICC of 0.96. The present study presents a novel tool for assessing sarcopenia and provides evidence in favor of feasibility and reliability of US measurement of MT at the anterior thigh level in rheumatology setting. Key Points • This study demonstrates that ultrasound (US) measurement of muscle thickness at the anterior thigh level is highly reliable, especially for the "anterior superior iliac spine (ASIS)" technique. • The short time needed to complete the US assessment highlights the feasibility of the proposed scanning protocols. • The simplicity and conciseness of the proposed techniques will allow other researchers and clinicians to use it for a fast assessment of sarcopenia.
超声(US)是评估肌肉减少症的一种很有前景的工具。我们旨在在风湿病学环境中测试两种超声扫描方案,以测量大腿前部水平的肌肉厚度(MT),并评估其可行性和可靠性。在研究的第一阶段,三名风湿病学家采用两种扫描方案,即前上棘(ASIS)和大转子技术,对19名连续患者进行了超声检查。在就最容易执行的扫描方案达成共识后,两名风湿病学家仅对40名连续患者采用了ASIS技术。记录了MT测量值以及双侧完成每个扫描方案所需的时间。两种技术完成超声检查所需的中位时间均不到5分钟,两者之间无显著差异(p = 0.64)。在第一阶段,我们发现所提出的扫描方案具有出色的观察者间可靠性,与大转子技术相比,ASIS技术的组内相关系数(ICC)更高但无统计学意义(ICC 0.97对ICC 0.92,p = 0.05)。ASIS技术的观察者内可靠性显著更高(ICC 0.97对ICC 0.92,p < 0.01)。在第二阶段,ASIS技术在更大样本上证实了其出色的观察者间可靠性,ICC为0.96。本研究提出了一种评估肌肉减少症的新工具,并为在风湿病学环境中超声测量大腿前部水平MT的可行性和可靠性提供了证据。要点 • 本研究表明,超声测量大腿前部水平的肌肉厚度高度可靠,尤其是对于“前上棘(ASIS)”技术。 • 完成超声评估所需的时间短突出了所提出扫描方案的可行性。 • 所提出技术的简单性和简洁性将使其他研究人员和临床医生能够将其用于快速评估肌肉减少症。