University of Roehampton, UK.
University of Sheffield, UK.
Transcult Psychiatry. 2023 Dec;60(6):879-890. doi: 10.1177/1363461520962887. Epub 2020 Oct 11.
Experiencing the continued presence of the deceased is common among the bereaved, whether as a sensory perception or as a felt presence. This phenomenon has been researched from psychological and psychiatric perspectives during the last five decades. Such experiences have been also documented in the ethnographic literature but, despite the extensive cross-cultural research in the area, anthropological data has generally not been considered in the psychological literature about this phenomenon. This paper provides an overview aimed at bridging these two areas of knowledge, and approaches the post-bereavement perception or hallucination of the deceased in cultural context. Ongoing debates are addressed from the vantage point of ethnographic and clinical case study research focusing on the cultural repertoires (in constant flux as cultures change) from which these experiences are labelled as desirable and normal, on the one hand, or as dangerous and pathological, on the other.
丧亲者经历逝者持续存在是很常见的,无论是作为一种感官知觉还是一种感觉存在。在过去的五十年中,这种现象已经从心理学和精神病学的角度进行了研究。这种体验也在民族志文献中有记载,但尽管在该领域进行了广泛的跨文化研究,人类学数据在关于这种现象的心理学文献中通常未被考虑。本文旨在弥合这两个知识领域的鸿沟,并从文化背景的角度探讨丧亲后的逝者感知或幻觉。本文从民族志和临床案例研究的角度探讨了正在进行的争论,重点关注这些体验被标记为理想和正常的文化剧目(随着文化的变化而不断变化),以及被标记为危险和病态的文化剧目。