Liu H L, Liu X G, Tian Y M, Ni L, Zheng D X
Department of Prosthodontics, Capital Medical University School of Stomatology, Beijing 100050, China.
Medical Research & Biometrics Center, National Center for Cardiovascular Diseases, Beijing 100037, China.
Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2020 Oct 9;55(10):737-742. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20200506-00244.
To explore the accuracy of occlusal contacts on digital model made by intraoral scanner. Twenty healthy subjects [6 males, 14 females, (24.4±1.4) years old] with intact dentition were randomly recruited from postgraduate students in Capital Medical University School of Stomatology who volunteered to participate in this study. For each participant, the 2nd and 3rd quadrant of natural dentition was scanned. A diagnostic test design was performed. The occlusal contacts of the maximal intercuspal position (MIP) were extracted with the transillumination of silicone interocclusal records, and the extraction threshold was set as ≤50 μm. Intraoral scanning system was used to scan in MIP and generate occlusal contacts on digital model. Five groups were designed as test groups according to included tooth position: group 1 (buccal scanning ranged from tooth 21 to 23), group 2 (buccal scanning ranged from tooth 23 to 26), group 3 (buccal scanning ranged from tooth 24 to 26), group 4 (buccal scanning ranged from tooth 25 to 26), group 5 (buccal scanning ranged from tooth 21 to 26). Five groups occlusal contacts on digital model were generated respectively. According to the relevant literature, the upper occlusal surface was divided into 28 partitions, and the accuracy of occlusal contacts on digital model was calculated with the transillumination of silicone interocclusal records as the reference standard. Subgroup analysis was performed according to anterior teeth area, premolars area and molars area. The accuracy of occlusal contacts on digital models of the half dentition in five buccal scanning positions were: group 1 (86.8%), group 2 (92.0%), group 3 (90.7%), group 4 (91.1%), group 5 (90.4%), and the accuracy of occlusal contacts in group 1 was significantly lower than those in the other four groups (<0.05). The accuracy of anterior teeth area were 85.6%-93.9%; the accuracy of premolar area were 92.5%-94.4%; the accuracy of molar area were 77.3%-93.6%, group 1 was significantly lower than those in the group 4 in molars area (<0.05), the accuracy of anterior area was statistically less than premolars area and molars area in group 1 (<0.05). There was no statistical difference in pairwise comparison between the three sections (>0.05). The digital models scanned intraoral methods provide accurate, quantitative measures of occlusal contacts when transillumination contacts are the reference standard.
探讨口腔内扫描仪制作的数字模型上咬合接触的准确性。从首都医科大学口腔医学院自愿参与本研究的研究生中随机招募20名牙列完整的健康受试者[6名男性,14名女性,(24.4±1.4)岁]。对每位受试者的天然牙列的第二和第三象限进行扫描。采用诊断性试验设计。用硅橡胶咬合记录透照法提取最大牙尖交错位(MIP)的咬合接触,提取阈值设定为≤50μm。使用口腔内扫描系统在MIP位进行扫描,并在数字模型上生成咬合接触。根据纳入的牙位将其分为五组作为试验组:第1组(颊侧扫描范围为21至23号牙),第2组(颊侧扫描范围为23至26号牙),第3组(颊侧扫描范围为牙24至26),第4组(颊侧扫描范围为牙25至26),第5组(颊侧扫描范围为牙21至26)。分别生成五组数字模型上的咬合接触。根据相关文献,将上颌咬合面分为28个分区,以硅橡胶咬合记录透照法为参考标准计算数字模型上咬合接触的准确性。根据前牙区、前磨牙区和磨牙区进行亚组分析。五个颊侧扫描位置的半口牙列数字模型上咬合接触的准确性分别为:第1组(86.8%),第2组(92.0%),第3组(90.7%),第4组(91.1%),第5组(90.4%),第1组咬合接触的准确性显著低于其他四组(<0.05)。前牙区的准确性为85.6%~93.9%;前磨牙区的准确性为92.5%~94.4%;磨牙区的准确性为77.3%~93.6%,第1组在磨牙区显著低于第4组(<0.05),第1组在前牙区的准确性在统计学上低于前磨牙区和磨牙区(<0.05)。三组之间两两比较差异无统计学意义(>0.05)。当以透照接触为参考标准时,口腔内扫描方法制作的数字模型能提供准确、定量的咬合接触测量结果。