Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, 615 N Wolfe St, Baltimore, MD, 21205, USA.
Oregon State University, 2250 SW Jefferson Way, Corvallis, OR, 97331, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2020 Dec;266:113373. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2020.113373. Epub 2020 Sep 19.
Little empirical research exists on the effects of health work on Community Health Workers' (CHWs') social relationships and status, yet these factors are important in understanding the broad social and behavioral drivers and impacts of CHW programs. This is particularly true for unpaid CHWs. Engaging with others as a CHW might help a worker to embody a valued role in society as a selfless, caring individual; or it might strengthen bonds with others and improve social networks and social capital. By combining qualitative, ethnographic, and survey data collected in rural Amhara, Ethiopia from 2013 to 2016, we evaluated the extent to which unpaid female workers in Ethiopia's Women's Development Army (WDA) were better able than their peers to achieve cultural consonance by building desired social connections or fulfilling locally salient models of virtuous womanhood. We conducted a cultural consensus survey (n = 74) and measured cultural consonance in a larger survey of adult women, including WDA leaders (n = 422). We also conducted participant observation and interviews with health officials, local health staff, and WDA leaders. In our study site, WDA leaders were more able than other women to fulfill the cultural ideal of having connections to various government officials. Yet these connections often did not lead to the benefits that WDA leaders hoped for. Also, in contrast to the findings of many other studies, achieving greater cultural consonance was not significantly associated with reduced psychological distress in this population. For women in this rural context, meanwhile, psychological distress is strongly associated with food and water insecurity, stressful life events, and social support. These findings point to the importance of social, economic and psychological support for rural women in Amhara, and specifically for unpaid CHWs.
关于卫生工作对社区卫生工作者(CHW)的社会关系和地位的影响,几乎没有实证研究,但这些因素对于理解 CHW 项目的广泛社会和行为驱动因素以及影响至关重要。对于无薪酬的 CHW 来说尤其如此。作为 CHW 与他人互动可能有助于工人在社会中体现出无私、关爱他人的有价值角色;或者可能会加强与他人的联系,改善社交网络和社会资本。我们结合了 2013 年至 2016 年在埃塞俄比亚阿姆哈拉州农村地区收集的定性、民族志和调查数据,评估了埃塞俄比亚妇女发展军(WDA)中的无薪酬女性工人通过建立理想的社会联系或实现当地有价值的女性美德模式,在多大程度上比同龄人更能够实现文化和谐。我们进行了文化共识调查(n=74),并在对成年女性的更大调查中衡量了文化和谐度,包括 WDA 领导人(n=422)。我们还对卫生官员、当地卫生工作人员和 WDA 领导人进行了参与观察和访谈。在我们的研究地点,WDA 领导人比其他女性更有能力与各种政府官员建立联系,从而实现文化理想。然而,这些联系往往没有给 WDA 领导人带来他们所希望的好处。此外,与许多其他研究的发现相反,在这个人群中,实现更高的文化和谐与降低心理困扰没有显著关联。与此同时,在这种农村背景下,对于女性来说,心理困扰与食物和水不安全、生活压力事件和社会支持密切相关。这些发现表明,对于阿姆哈拉的农村妇女,特别是对于无薪酬的 CHW,提供社会、经济和心理支持非常重要。