Faculty of Health and Applied Sciences, University of the West of England, Bristol, UK.
Faculty of Health and Applied Sciences, University of the West of England, Bristol, UK.
Musculoskelet Sci Pract. 2020 Dec;50:102271. doi: 10.1016/j.msksp.2020.102271. Epub 2020 Oct 10.
Chronic musculoskeletal pain including osteoarthritis (OA) can significantly limit the functional independence of individuals. The spine and hip and knee are predominantly affected; management guidelines for each recommend exercise and education to support self-management.
This study investigated the effectiveness of a generic exercise and self-management intervention for people over-50 with hip/knee OA and/or lower back pain compared to continued GP management.
Single blind, cluster randomised controlled trial.
Participants who had previously consulted with hip/knee OA and/or chronic lower back pain were recruited from 45 GP practices in SW England. Practices were randomly allocated to receive continued GP care (control) or continued GP care and a 6-week group exercise and self-management intervention facilitated by a physiotherapist and located in a community-based physiotherapy department. The primary outcome measure was the Dysfunction Index of the Short Musculoskeletal Functional Assessment (DI-SMFA) measured at six month post-rehabilitation.
349 participants were recruited and allocated to the intervention (n = 170) or control (n = 179) arms; the attrition rate was 13% at the 6 month primary end-point. One minor adverse event in the intervention group that required no medical input was reported. Intervention arm participants reported better function at 6 months compared with continued GP management alone (-3.01 difference in DI-SMFA [95%CI -5.25, -0.76], p = 0.01).
A generic exercise and self-management intervention resulted in statistically significant changes in function after six-months compared with GP management alone, but clinical significance of these findings is less clear. This may be an effective way of managing group interventions for lower limb OA and chronic lower back pain.
慢性肌肉骨骼疼痛包括骨关节炎(OA)会严重限制个体的功能独立性。脊柱、髋关节和膝关节是主要受影响的部位;针对每种疾病的管理指南都建议进行运动和教育,以支持自我管理。
本研究调查了针对 50 岁以上髋/膝关节 OA 和/或下腰痛患者的通用运动和自我管理干预措施与持续 GP 管理相比的有效性。
单盲、整群随机对照试验。
参与者先前曾因髋/膝关节 OA 和/或慢性下腰痛就诊,从英格兰西南部的 45 家全科医生诊所招募。将诊所随机分配接受持续的 GP 护理(对照组)或持续的 GP 护理和由物理治疗师提供的为期 6 周的团体运动和自我管理干预,该干预在社区基础物理治疗部门进行。主要结局指标是康复后 6 个月时短肌肉骨骼功能评估(SMFA)的功能障碍指数(DI-SMFA)。
共招募 349 名参与者并分配到干预组(n=170)或对照组(n=179);在 6 个月的主要终点时,失访率为 13%。干预组报告了 1 例轻微不良事件,无需医疗干预。与单独接受 GP 管理相比,干预组参与者在 6 个月时的功能更好(DI-SMFA 差异为 3.01 [95%CI-5.25,-0.76],p=0.01)。
与单独接受 GP 管理相比,通用运动和自我管理干预在 6 个月后在功能方面有统计学意义的变化,但这些发现的临床意义不太明确。这可能是管理下肢 OA 和慢性下腰痛群体干预的有效方法。