School of Health Sciences, Robert Gordon University, Aberdeen, Scotland, UK.
Physiother Theory Pract. 2022 Sep;38(9):1245-1253. doi: 10.1080/09593985.2020.1827467. Epub 2020 Oct 20.
This study reports on the development of an outcome measure designed to evaluate pre-registration physiotherapy students' ability in performing core cardiorespiratory skills.
A four round, e- Delphi study using an international panel of expert cardiorespiratory physiotherapists involved in pre-registration student education was undertaken. In round one participants identified what they look for in students competently performing core cardio-respiratory physiotherapy assessment and treatment skills. These items were refined in rounds two and three. Item content validity score (iCVI) of ≥ 0.8 at round four identified consensus. Scale content validity index (SCVI) was calculated.
Response rate for round one was 46% (6/13). Additional experts were invited to participate and response rates increased to 71% (round 2), 88% (round 3) and 100% (round 4). Of the 207 items across the seven skills identified in round one, 140 were presented in round four. Of these, consensus was achieved for 128 items, with 12 being excluded. The SCVI was 0.907.
This e-Delphi study enabled the development of a draft outcome measure, which aims to assess performance of seven cardiorespiratory physiotherapy skills. This tool will enable rigorous evaluation of different education methods to establish their effectiveness. However, it is first necessary to establish construct validity and assess inter and intra-rater reliability.
本研究报告了一种旨在评估注册前物理治疗学生进行核心心肺技能能力的结果测量的开发。
采用四轮电子德尔菲研究法,邀请了国际心肺物理治疗专家组成员参与,对注册前学生教育进行了评估。在第一轮中,参与者确定了他们在熟练执行核心心肺物理治疗评估和治疗技能的学生中寻找的内容。这些项目在第二轮和第三轮中进行了细化。第四轮中 iCVI≥0.8 的项目内容有效性得分确定了共识。计算了量表内容有效性指数 (SCVI)。
第一轮的回复率为 46%(6/13)。邀请了更多的专家参与,回复率提高到了 71%(第二轮)、88%(第三轮)和 100%(第四轮)。在第一轮确定的 7 项技能中,有 207 项,其中有 140 项在第四轮中呈现。其中,128 项达成共识,12 项被排除。SCVI 为 0.907。
这项电子德尔菲研究使我们能够开发出一种草案的结果测量工具,旨在评估心肺物理治疗的 7 项技能。该工具将能够对不同的教育方法进行严格评估,以确定其有效性。然而,首先有必要建立结构有效性,并评估内部和外部评分者的可靠性。