Genomic Medicine Institute, Lerner Research Institute, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Cologne Center for Genomics, University of Cologne, Cologne, Germany.
Epilepsia. 2020 Nov;61(11):e179-e185. doi: 10.1111/epi.16717. Epub 2020 Oct 14.
Focal epilepsy (FE) is clinically highly heterogeneous. It has been shown recently that not only rare but also a subset of common genetic variants confer risk for FE. The relatively modest power of genetic studies in FE suggests a high genetic heterogeneity of FE when grouped as one disorder. We hypothesize that the clinical heterogeneity of FE is correlated with genetic heterogeneity on a common risk variant level. To test the hypothesis, we used an FE polygenic risk score "FE-PRS" that combines small effect sizes of thousands of common variants from the largest FE-GWAS (genome-wide association study) into a single measure. We grouped 414 individuals with FE according to common clinical features into subgroups, either by one feature at a time or by all features combined in a cluster analysis. We examined their association with FE-PRS compared to 20 435 matched population controls and observed heterogeneous FE-PRS burden among the subgroups. The highest phenotypic variance explained by FE-PRS was identified in a cluster analysis-defined FE subgroup where all individuals had unknown etiologies and psychiatric comorbidities, and the majority had early onset seizures. Our results indicate that genetic factors associated with FE have differential burden among FE subtypes. Future studies using better-powered FE-PRS might have clinical utility.
局灶性癫痫(FE)在临床上具有高度异质性。最近的研究表明,不仅罕见的遗传变异,而且常见遗传变异的亚组也会增加 FE 的风险。FE 的遗传研究相对效力较低,这表明将 FE 作为一种疾病进行分组时,其遗传异质性很高。我们假设 FE 的临床异质性与常见风险变异水平上的遗传异质性相关。为了验证这一假设,我们使用了一种 FE 多基因风险评分“FE-PRS”,该评分将来自最大 FE-GWAS(全基因组关联研究)的数千个常见变异的小效应大小组合成一个单一的度量标准。我们根据常见的临床特征将 414 名 FE 患者分为亚组,一次一个特征或通过聚类分析将所有特征组合在一起。我们将其与 20435 名匹配的人群对照进行比较,并观察到亚组之间存在 FE-PRS 负担的异质性。在聚类分析定义的 FE 亚组中,FE-PRS 解释的表型方差最大,该亚组中的所有患者病因不明且伴有精神共病,大多数患者的发病年龄较早。我们的研究结果表明,与 FE 相关的遗传因素在 FE 亚型之间存在不同的负担。未来使用更强大的 FE-PRS 的研究可能具有临床应用价值。