Department of Psychiatry, Fujita Health University School of Medicine, Toyoake, Aichi, 470-1192, Japan.
Department of Psychiatry, Fujita Health University School of Medicine, Toyoake, Aichi, 470-1192, Japan.
J Psychiatr Res. 2021 Jan;132:144-150. doi: 10.1016/j.jpsychires.2020.10.009. Epub 2020 Oct 16.
We investigated the association between discontinuation due to withdrawal of consent (DWC) in schizophrenia trials and the use of long-acting injectable antipsychotics (LAI-APs). In two categorical meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials, we compared DWC: individual and pooled LAI-APs vs. (1) placebo and (2) oral antipsychotics (OAPs). We also performed conducted a single-group meta-analysis to calculate the average DWC and a meta-regression analysis to examine the association between the results of the meta-analyses and factors related to study design, treatment, and patients. We identified 52 studies (total adult patients = 18,675, LAI-APs = 12,613, placebo = 2,083, and OAPs = 3,979; median study duration = 32 weeks). DWC was higher for LAI-aripiprazole than for the placebo [risk ratio (95% confidence interval) = 1.70 (1.23-2.39)]. Neither pooled nor individual LAI-APs differed from the placebo for fluphenazine, olanzapine, paliperidone, and risperidone or from the OAPs for aripiprazole, fluphenazine, haloperidol, olanzapine, paliperidone, risperidone, and zuclopenthixol. The average DWC of each LAI-AP was as follows: LAI-aripiprazole = 10.98%, LAI-fluphenazine = 7.65%, LAI-flupenthixol = 3.33%, LAI-haloperidol = 6.71%, LAI-olanzapine = 10.50%, LAI-paliperidone = 10.38%, LAI-perphenazine = 7.06%, LAI-risperidone = 10.39%, LAI-zuclopenthixol = 4.45%, pooled LAI-APs = 9.88%, and placebo = 11.17%. Meta-regression analysis demonstrated that publication year (β = 0.02), percentage of males (β = 0.02), and mean age (β = 0.05) were associated with an average DWC for pooled LAI-APs. Study duration (β = -0.03), percentage of males (β = 0.08), and patient status (β = -0.85) were associated with an average DWC for LAI-aripiprazole. Presence of a placebo arm (β = 1.60) was associated with an average DWC for LAI-fluphenazine. LAI-AP use was unlikely to be associated with DWC. Although the LAI-aripiprazole had a higher DWC than did the placebo, its average DWC was similar to other those of LAI-APs.
我们调查了精神分裂症试验中因撤回同意而停药(DWC)与使用长效注射抗精神病药物(LAI-APs)之间的关系。在两项随机对照试验的分类荟萃分析中,我们比较了 DWC:单独和汇总的 LAI-APs 与(1)安慰剂和(2)口服抗精神病药(OAPs)。我们还进行了一项单组荟萃分析,以计算平均 DWC,并进行荟萃回归分析,以检查荟萃分析结果与与研究设计、治疗和患者相关的因素之间的关联。我们确定了 52 项研究(总成年患者=18675,LAI-APs=12613,安慰剂=2083,OAPs=3979;中位研究持续时间=32 周)。与安慰剂相比,LAI-阿立哌唑的 DWC 更高[风险比(95%置信区间)=1.70(1.23-2.39)]。与安慰剂相比,聚集体或个体 LAI-APs 在氟奋乃静、奥氮平、帕利哌酮和利培酮方面没有差异,在阿立哌唑、氟奋乃静、氟哌啶醇、奥氮平、帕利哌酮、利培酮和齐拉西酮方面与 OAPs 也没有差异。每个 LAI-AP 的平均 DWC 如下:LAI-阿立哌唑=10.98%,LAI-氟奋乃静=7.65%,LAI-氟哌啶醇=6.71%,LAI-奥氮平=10.50%,LAI-帕利哌酮=10.38%,LAI-奋乃静=10.39%,LAI-齐拉西酮=4.45%,聚集体 LAI-APs=9.88%,安慰剂=11.17%。荟萃回归分析表明,出版年份(β=0.02)、男性比例(β=0.02)和平均年龄(β=0.05)与聚集体 LAI-APs 的平均 DWC 相关。研究持续时间(β=-0.03)、男性比例(β=0.08)和患者状况(β=-0.85)与 LAI-阿立哌唑的平均 DWC 相关。安慰剂组的存在(β=1.60)与 LAI-氟奋乃静的平均 DWC 相关。LAI-AP 的使用不太可能与 DWC 相关。尽管 LAI-阿立哌唑的 DWC 高于安慰剂,但它的平均 DWC 与其他 LAI-APs 相似。