Suppr超能文献

关于“性别”和“性”这两个术语的概念争议。

Conceptual controversies regarding the terms Gender and Sex.

机构信息

First Department of Psychiatry, University of Athens, Eginition Hospital, Athens, Greece.

出版信息

Psychiatriki. 2020 Jul-Sep;31(3):271-274. doi: 10.22365/jpsych.2020.313.271.

Abstract

I have been following lately the debate that has emerged in the Greek and International literature regarding the terms "sex" and "gender". Traditionally, the term sex refers to the assignment of gender at birth by the obstetrician or the midwife, based on the external genitalia. They declared the sex of the newly born baby as male or female, without any other graduation. Therefore, the term sex is a nonflexible categorical concept. It is quite difficult to comprehend the sense of "a little bit male" or "a little bit female", as it is not possible to comprehend the sense of "a little bit pregnant". At the preface of the DSM-5, the American Psychiatric Association presents its intention to propose the new dimensional classification of psychiatric symptoms, based on the rationale that the present categorical system does not apply to clinical and research needs.1 In that case, it would be difficult (if not impossible), to achieve the graduation of the term "sex", which refers to the biological definition. Therefore, in my opinion, there is a trend to bring back the term "gender", where a graduation is feasible, and dimensions can be applied. The term gender contains the social definition of reproductive behavior, which can be detached from the reproductive role per se. The term "gender" was recalled in 1955 by the well-known author J. Money, in order to indicate the social effect on the development of the behavior of "sex", and therefore he used at the beginning the term G-I/R, which refers to Gender Identity Role.2 The short term "gender", that derived from the abovementioned term, came up the recent years and was widely used, putting aside the clearly biologic, non-flexible term "sex".3 The term "gender" spread in the literature, especially when it was adopted by the women rights' movement (feminism), in order to highlight the "socially constructed" differences between the two sexes. The term "gender" has given ground to the proposal of several graduations of sexual behavior. Zucker et al at in a recent article report ten different gender behaviors such as agender, gender nonconforming, gender neutral, gender variant, gender queer, gender dysphoria, gender fluid, bigender, nonbinary, transgender.4 Several of these identities overlap considerably. In the Greek language, the use of the terms gender and sex (male, female) may lead to confusion, since they are attributed by the same term «φύλο». Additionally, the use of the term "gender" in Greek as «γένος» may also lead to misunderstandings and misconceptions, as it happened lately with the law regarding the name change in the identification card (ID) of people with gender dysphoria. Actually, the latter term refers to masculinity or femininity, as these are configured by the social background. In my opinion, in the Greek language it would be better to use the term "gender" referring to its social delineation, meaning "social sex", social sex identity. The term "gender dysphoria" could be attributed as «δυσφορία γένους», in order to distance itself from the dysphoria caused by dysplasias of genitalia which are refered to in the literature as "intersexual disorders" and could be referred to as "disorders of the development of genitalia".

摘要

我最近一直在关注希腊和国际文献中出现的关于“性”和“性别”这两个术语的争论。传统上,术语“性”是指产科医生或助产士根据外生殖器在出生时分配的性别。他们宣布新生儿的性别为男性或女性,没有任何其他分级。因此,术语“性”是一个非灵活的类别概念。很难理解“有点男性”或“有点女性”的意思,因为不可能理解“有点怀孕”的意思。在美国精神病学会 (American Psychiatric Association) 出版的《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》(DSM-5) 前言中,该协会表示打算提出基于合理理由的新的精神症状维度分类,即目前的分类系统不适用于临床和研究需求。1在这种情况下,很难(如果不是不可能的话)实现术语“性”的分级,因为它指的是生物定义。因此,在我看来,有一种趋势是引入术语“性别”,其中可以进行分级和应用维度。术语“性别”包含了生殖行为的社会定义,可以与生殖角色本身分离。术语“性别”于 1955 年被著名作家 J. 莫尼(J. Money)重新使用,以表明“性别”行为的发展受到社会的影响,因此他最初使用了术语 G-I/R,指的是性别认同角色。2近年来,这个简短的术语“性别”得到了广泛的使用,取代了明显的、非灵活的术语“性”。3术语“性别”在文献中得到了传播,尤其是在被妇女权利运动(女权主义)采用时,以突出两性之间的“社会建构”差异。术语“性别”为提出几种性行为的分级提供了依据。Zucker 等人在最近的一篇文章中报告了十种不同的性别行为,如无性别、性别不一致、性别中立、性别变异、性别酷儿、性别焦虑、性别流动、双性别、非二元性别、跨性别。4这些身份中的许多都有很大的重叠。在希腊语中,使用性别和性(男性、女性)这两个术语可能会导致混淆,因为它们是由同一个术语“φύλο”来表示的。此外,在希腊语中使用术语“性别”表示“γένος”也可能导致误解和误解,最近在与性别焦虑症患者身份证(ID)上姓名变更相关的法律中就发生了这种情况。实际上,后者指的是男性气质或女性气质,因为这些是由社会背景构成的。在我看来,在希腊语中,最好使用术语“性别”来表示其社会划分,意思是“社会性别”、社会性别认同。术语“性别焦虑症”可以归因于“δυσφορία γένους”,以使其与因生殖器畸形引起的焦虑症区分开来,这种焦虑症在文献中被称为“两性畸形”,可以被称为“生殖器发育障碍”。

文献检索

告别复杂PubMed语法,用中文像聊天一样搜索,搜遍4000万医学文献。AI智能推荐,让科研检索更轻松。

立即免费搜索

文件翻译

保留排版,准确专业,支持PDF/Word/PPT等文件格式,支持 12+语言互译。

免费翻译文档

深度研究

AI帮你快速写综述,25分钟生成高质量综述,智能提取关键信息,辅助科研写作。

立即免费体验