Davidson M K, Lindsey J R, Davis J K
Department of Comparative Medicine, University of Alabama, Birmingham 35294.
Isr J Med Sci. 1987 Jun;23(6):551-5.
There are two broad classes of models: those based on analogy (similar structures imply similar functions), and those based on homology (structures derived from the same evolutionary precursor have the same or similar functions). There are four main categories of animal models: 1) induced or experimental models, that attempt to reproduce conditions found in the original species, 2) spontaneous or natural models, that are recognized as being similar to some condition in the original species, 3) negative or nonreactive models, that are the normal counterparts of a disease model, and 4) orphan models, that are animal diseases for which no human or animal counterpart is known. The selection of any model, but particularly animal models, for research should be based on the following considerations: 1) appropriateness as an analog, 2) transferability of information, 3) genetic uniformity of organisms, where applicable, 4) background knowledge of biological properties, 5) cost and availability, 6) generalizability of the results, 7) ease of and adaptability to experimental manipulation, 8) ecological consequences, and 9) ethical implications. The criteria for selection or rejection of particular animal models also include customary practice within a particular discipline, the existence of diseases or conditions that might complicate results, the existing body of knowledge on the problem under consideration, and special features of the animal, such as unique responses or microflora, that may make a particular species useful.
一类基于类比(相似结构意味着相似功能),另一类基于同源性(源自同一进化前体的结构具有相同或相似功能)。动物模型主要有四类:1)诱导或实验模型,旨在重现原物种中发现的状况;2)自发或自然模型,被认为与原物种中的某些状况相似;3)阴性或无反应模型,是疾病模型的正常对应物;4)孤儿模型,是指未知人类或动物对应物的动物疾病。选择任何模型,尤其是动物模型进行研究时,应基于以下考虑因素:1)作为类比的适用性;2)信息的可转移性;3)生物体的基因一致性(如适用);4)生物学特性的背景知识;5)成本和可获得性;6)结果的可推广性;7)实验操作的难易程度和适应性;8)生态后果;9)伦理影响。选择或拒绝特定动物模型的标准还包括特定学科内的惯例、可能使结果复杂化的疾病或状况的存在、关于所考虑问题的现有知识体系,以及动物的特殊特征,如独特反应或微生物群落,这些可能使特定物种有用。