Jauhiainen Alexandra, Scheepers Lieke E J M, Fuhlbrigge Anne L, Harrison Tim, Zangrilli James, Garcia Gil Esther, Gustafson Per, Fagerås Malin, Da Silva Carla A
BioPharma Early Biometrics and Statistical Innovation, Data Science & AI, BioPharmaceuticals R&D, AstraZeneca, Gothenburg, Sweden.
Shared first authors.
ERJ Open Res. 2020 Oct 19;6(4). doi: 10.1183/23120541.00246-2020. eCollection 2020 Oct.
CompEx Asthma, a novel composite end-point combining severe exacerbations (SevEx) with asthma-worsening events, was recently developed. Further characterisation of CompEx Asthma is needed to illustrate the applicability of this end-point. The objective was to evaluate CompEx Asthma as a rate end-point to determine how seasonal and geographical factors impact this novel outcome.
Seven 24-56-week randomised controlled trials of budesonide/formoterol (BUD/FORM) and benralizumab were analysed. Annualised event rates (AERs) and treatment effects (hazard ratio (HR)) were analysed with Poisson and Andersen-Gill models, respectively. Seasonality was analysed by month and five geographical regions were evaluated.
The studies included 10 815 patients (63% female, mean age 42-49 years). CompEx Asthma AER mirrored seasonal variations in SevEx AER. CompEx Asthma AERs were higher SevEx in BUD/FORM and benralizumab trials (range 2.7-4.5-fold and 1.3-2.0-fold increase, respectively) and were less variable SevEx between regions (ratios of greatest:smallest AERs: 1.36 for CompEx 2.28 for SevEx (BUD/FORM); 1.81 for CompEx 2.22 for SevEx (benralizumab)). Treatment effects for CompEx Asthma and SevEx were generally similar across regions and months. However, in Eastern Europe, where SevEx rates were lowest, treatment effect was greater with CompEx Asthma SevEx, reaching statistical significance in the benralizumab studies (HR (95% CI): 0.67 (0.53-0.85) 0.87 (0.65-1.15)).
This study confirmed the reliability of CompEx Asthma as a rate end-point and allowed detection of variations in seasonal SevEx rates, reduction of variation in rates across regions and potential greater sensitivity to treatment effects.
复合终点哮喘(CompEx Asthma)是一种将严重哮喘发作(SevEx)与哮喘病情恶化事件相结合的新型复合终点,最近已被开发出来。需要对复合终点哮喘进行进一步的特征描述,以说明该终点的适用性。目的是评估复合终点哮喘作为一种发生率终点,以确定季节和地理因素如何影响这一新型结局。
分析了7项关于布地奈德/福莫特罗(BUD/FORM)和贝那利珠单抗的24 - 56周随机对照试验。分别采用泊松模型和安德森 - 吉尔模型分析年化事件率(AERs)和治疗效果(风险比(HR))。按月分析季节性,并评估了五个地理区域。
这些研究纳入了10815名患者(63%为女性,平均年龄42 - 49岁)。复合终点哮喘年化事件率反映了严重哮喘发作年化事件率的季节性变化。在布地奈德/福莫特罗和贝那利珠单抗试验中,复合终点哮喘年化事件率高于严重哮喘发作年化事件率(分别增加2.7 - 4.5倍和1.3 - 2.0倍),且各区域间的变异性小于严重哮喘发作年化事件率(复合终点哮喘最大年化事件率与最小年化事件率之比为1.36,严重哮喘发作年化事件率(布地奈德/福莫特罗)为2.28;复合终点哮喘为1.81,严重哮喘发作年化事件率(贝那利珠单抗)为2.22)。复合终点哮喘和严重哮喘发作的治疗效果在各区域和各月份总体相似。然而,在严重哮喘发作率最低的东欧,复合终点哮喘的治疗效果大于严重哮喘发作,在贝那利珠单抗研究中达到统计学显著性(风险比(95%置信区间):0.67(0.53 - 0.85)对比0.87(0.65 - 1.15))。
本研究证实了复合终点哮喘作为发生率终点的可靠性,并能够检测季节性严重哮喘发作率的变化,减少各区域间发生率的变异性,以及对治疗效果可能具有更高的敏感性。