Patel Veena, Gillies Clare, Patel Prashanth, Davies Timothy, Hansdot Sajeda, Lee Virginia, Lakhani Mayur, Khunti Kamlesh, Gupta Pankaj
Department of Rheumatology, University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust, Leicester, UK.
Diabetes Research Centre, University of Leicester, Leicester General Hospital, Leicester, UK.
BJGP Open. 2020 Dec 15;4(5). doi: 10.3399/bjgpopen20X101090. Print 2020 Dec.
Since 2000, vitamin D requests have increased 2-6 fold with no evidence of a corresponding improvement in the health of the population. The ease of vitamin D requesting may contribue to the rapid rise in its demand and, hence, pragmatic interventions to reduce vitamin D test ordering are warranted.
To study the effect on vitamin D requests following a redesign of the electronic forms used in primary care. In addition, any potential harms were studied and the potential cost-savings associated with the intervention were evaluated.
DESIGN & SETTING: An interventional study took place within primary care across Leicestershire, England.
The intervention was a redesign of the electronic laboratory request form for primary care practitioners across the county. Data were collected on vitamin D requests for a 6-month period prior to the change (October 2016 to March 2017) and the corresponding 6-month period post-intervention (October 2017 to March 2018), data were also collected on vitamin D, calcium, and phosphate levels.
The number of requests for vitamin D decreased by 14 918 (36.2%) following the intervention. Changes in the median calcium and phosphate were not clinically significant. Cost-modelling suggested that if such an intervention was implemented across primary care in the UK, there would be a potential annual saving to the NHS of £38 712 606.
A simple pragmatic redesign of the electronic request form for vitamin D test led to a significant reduction in vitamin D requests without any adverse effect on the quality of care.
自2000年以来,维生素D检测申请量增加了2至6倍,而没有证据表明人群健康状况有相应改善。维生素D检测申请的便捷性可能导致其需求迅速上升,因此,有必要采取务实的干预措施来减少维生素D检测的开具。
研究初级保健中使用的电子表格重新设计后对维生素D检测申请的影响。此外,研究了任何潜在危害,并评估了与该干预措施相关的潜在成本节约。
在英国莱斯特郡的初级保健机构内进行了一项干预性研究。
干预措施是对全县初级保健从业者的电子实验室检测申请表进行重新设计。收集了变更前6个月(2016年10月至2017年3月)和干预后相应6个月(2017年10月至2018年3月)的维生素D检测申请数据,还收集了维生素D、钙和磷水平的数据。
干预后维生素D检测申请数量减少了14918份(36.2%)。钙和磷中位数的变化在临床上无显著意义。成本模型显示,如果在英国的初级保健机构中实施这样的干预措施,国民保健服务体系(NHS)每年可能节省38712606英镑。
对维生素D检测电子申请表进行简单务实的重新设计,可显著减少维生素D检测申请,且对医疗质量没有任何不利影响。