Hatlevik Ida Katrine Riksaasen, Hovdenak Sylvi Stenersen
Department of Teacher Education and School Research, Faculty of Educational Sciences, University of Oslo, Oslo 0317, Norway.
Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Tromsø - The Arctic University of Norway, Tromsø, Norway.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2020 Oct 30;11:807-816. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S266960. eCollection 2020.
Transformative learning theory offers medical educators a particularly relevant insight into student learning. Transformative learning involves critically reflecting on assumptions and actions using empirical research methods and participating in a continuing discourse to validate the best reflective judgement and act according to new insights. The purpose of this paper is to investigate medical students' experiences with transformative learning activities and empirically and theoretically explain how these activities contribute to their understanding of the interplay between theoretical knowledge and professional practice, thereby creating a sense of coherence in medical education.
This paper analyzes the data from interviews with 40 medical students derived from a qualitative longitudinal research project in Norway from 2012 through 2018.
Students characterize linking theoretical knowledge with professional practice, experiencing authentic placement situations with real patients, and discussing and critically reflecting on cases and professional practice with experienced doctors as learning activities that transformed their understanding of professional practice. These transformative learning activities influenced students' perceptions of educational content and demands as being comprehensible, manageable, and meaningful, which are the core components of "sensing coherence" in professional education. Moreover, experiencing a lack of knowledge in either case-based learning on campus or when meeting patients in clinical placements motivates students to pursue further theoretical studies.
Medical education includes rich opportunities to use transformative learning activities both on campus and at clinical placement sites, but it is not given that these types of learning activities are present in the teaching offered at all the various learning sites; thus, enhanced awareness of why and how to promote transformative learning is required among medical educators.
变革性学习理论为医学教育工作者提供了与学生学习特别相关的见解。变革性学习包括运用实证研究方法批判性地反思假设和行动,并参与持续的讨论以验证最佳反思判断,并根据新见解采取行动。本文的目的是调查医学生在变革性学习活动中的经历,并从实证和理论上解释这些活动如何有助于他们理解理论知识与专业实践之间的相互作用,从而在医学教育中营造一种连贯感。
本文分析了2012年至2018年在挪威进行的一项定性纵向研究项目中对40名医学生的访谈数据。
学生们将将理论知识与专业实践联系起来、体验与真实患者的真实实习情境,以及与经验丰富的医生讨论并批判性地反思病例和专业实践描述为改变他们对专业实践理解的学习活动。这些变革性学习活动影响了学生对教育内容和要求的认知,使其具有可理解性、可管理性和有意义性,而这些是专业教育中“感知连贯性”的核心组成部分。此外,无论是在校园内的案例学习中还是在临床实习中接触患者时,体验到知识的不足都会促使学生继续进行理论学习。
医学教育在校园和临床实习地点都提供了丰富的机会来开展变革性学习活动,但并非所有不同学习地点提供的教学中都存在这类学习活动;因此,医学教育工作者需要提高对促进变革性学习的原因和方式的认识。