Department of Gastrointestinal Surgery, Stavanger University Hospital, Stavanger, Norway.
Department of Clinical Medicine, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway.
Ann Surg. 2021 Feb 1;273(2):208-216. doi: 10.1097/SLA.0000000000004583.
To model the risk of admitting silent COVID-19-infected patients to surgery with subsequent risk of severe pulmonary complications and mortality.
With millions of operations cancelled during the COVID-19 pandemic, pressure is mounting to reopen and increase surgical activity. The risk of admitting patients who have silent SARS-Cov-2 infection to surgery is not well investigated, but surgery on patients with COVID-19 is associated with poor outcomes. We aimed to model the risk of operating on nonsymptomatic infected individuals and associated risk of perioperative adverse outcomes and death.
We developed 2 sets of models to evaluate the risk of admitting silent COVID-19-infected patients to surgery. A static model let the underlying infection rate (R rate) and the gross population-rate of surgery vary. In a stochastic model, the dynamics of the COVID-19 prevalence and a fixed population-rate of surgery was considered. We generated uncertainty intervals (UIs) for our estimates by running low and high scenarios using the lower and upper 90% uncertainty limits. The modelling was applied for high-income regions (eg, United Kingdom (UK), USA (US) and European Union without UK (EU27), and for the World (WORLD) based on the WHO standard population.
Both models provided concerning rates of perioperative risk over a 24-months period. For the US, the modelled rates were 92,000 (UI 68,000-124,000) pulmonary complications and almost 30,000 deaths (UI 22,000-40·000), respectively; for Europe, some 131,000 patients (UI 97,000-178,000) with pulmonary complications and close to 47,000 deaths (UI 34,000-63,000) were modelled. For the UK, the model suggested a median daily number of operations on silently infected ranging between 25 and 90, accumulating about 18,700 (UI 13,700-25,300) perioperative pulmonary complications and 6400 (UI 4600-8600) deaths. In high-income regions combined, we estimated around 259,000 (UI 191,000-351,000) pulmonary complications and 89,000 deaths (UI 65,000-120,000). For the WORLD, even low surgery rates estimated a global number of 1.2 million pulmonary complications and 350,000 deaths.
The model highlights a considerable risk of admitting patients with silent COVID-19 to surgery with an associated risk for adverse perioperative outcomes and deaths. Strategies to avoid excessive complications and deaths after surgery during the pandemic are needed.
建立模型以评估无症状 COVID-19 感染者接受手术的风险,及其术后发生严重肺部并发症和死亡的风险。
在 COVID-19 大流行期间,数以百万计的手术被取消,人们正面临着增加手术量和重新开放的压力。然而,对于无症状 SARS-CoV-2 感染者接受手术的风险,目前尚未得到充分研究,但 COVID-19 患者的手术预后较差。我们旨在建立模型以评估对无症状感染患者进行手术的风险,以及围手术期不良结局和死亡的风险。
我们建立了 2 种模型来评估无症状 COVID-19 感染者接受手术的风险。静态模型允许基础感染率(R 率)和总手术率发生变化。在随机模型中,考虑了 COVID-19 流行的动态变化和固定的手术率。我们通过使用较低和较高的 90%不确定性区间来运行低和高情景,为我们的估计生成不确定性区间(UI)。该模型适用于高收入地区(例如英国、美国和无英国的欧盟 27 国,以及基于世界卫生组织标准人口的世界)。
这两种模型在 24 个月的时间内都提供了有关围手术期风险的令人担忧的结果。在美国,模拟的肺部并发症发生率为 92000 例(UI 68000-124000),接近 30000 例死亡(UI 22000-40000);在欧洲,模拟的肺部并发症患者约为 131000 例(UI 97000-178000),接近 47000 例死亡(UI 34000-63000)。在英国,模型提示每天对无症状感染者进行手术的中位数在 25 到 90 例之间,累计约有 18700 例(UI 13700-25300)围手术期肺部并发症和 6400 例(UI 4600-8600)死亡。在高收入地区,我们估计约有 259000 例(UI 191000-351000)肺部并发症和 89000 例死亡(UI 65000-120000)。对于全球范围,即使手术率较低,也估计会有 120 万例肺部并发症和 35 万例死亡。
该模型强调了对无症状 COVID-19 感染者进行手术存在相当大的风险,这与术后不良结局和死亡的风险相关。在大流行期间,需要采取策略来避免手术相关的并发症和死亡。