Remigio-Baker Rosemay A, Kiser Seth, Ferdosi Hamid, Gregory Emma, Engel Scot, Sebesta Sean, Beauchamp Daniel, Malik Saafan, Scher Ann, Hinds Sidney R
Defense and Veterans Brain Injury Center, Silver Spring, MD, United States.
Henry M. Jackson Foundation for the Advancement of Military Medicine, Bethesda, MD, United States.
Front Neurol. 2020 Oct 15;11:559311. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2020.559311. eCollection 2020.
Headache is a common symptom reported following concussion/mild traumatic brain injury. The Department of Defense's clinical recommendation (CR) describes guidance for primary care providers for the management of post-traumatic headache (PTH) in Service members. The objective of this study is to examine the association between training on the CR with provider clinical practice, patient behaviors, and symptom recovery. Participants were healthcare providers and two patient groups (one receiving care as usual [CAU] and another receiving care after provider training on PTH CR [CR+]). Providers were interviewed at three time points: (1) prior to CAU enrollment; (2) after CAU enrollment, but prior to training; and (3) after CR+ follow-up. Data from the second and third provider interview were used to evaluate a potential difference between provider practices pre- and post-training ( = 13). Patients were enrolled within 6 months of concussion. Patient outcomes (including neurobehavioral and headache symptoms) were assessed at three time-points: within 72 h ( = 35), at 1-week ( = 34) and at 1-month post-enrollment ( = 27). Most follow-up care reported by providers were recommended within 72 h of initial visit post-training vs. >1 week pre-training. Additionally, providers reported a greater number of visits based on patient symptoms after training than before. Post-training, most providers reported referring patients to higher level of care "as needed," if not "very rarely," compared to 25% reported referrals prior to training. At 1-week post-enrollment the CR+ patient group reported more frequent medical provider visits compared to the CAU group. This trend was reversed at the 1-month follow-up whereby more CAU reported seeing a medical provider compared to CR+. By 1-week post-enrollment, fewer patients in the CR+ group reported being referred to any other providers or specialists compared to the CAU group. No differences in patient outcomes by provider training was found. The study results demonstrate the feasibility of training on the Management of Headache Following Concussion CR in order to change provider practices by promoting timely care, and promoting patient compliance as shown through improvement in follow-up visits and more monitoring within the primary care clinic.
头痛是脑震荡/轻度创伤性脑损伤后常见的症状。美国国防部的临床建议(CR)为初级保健提供者提供了管理军人创伤后头痛(PTH)的指导。本研究的目的是探讨关于该临床建议的培训与提供者临床实践、患者行为和症状恢复之间的关联。参与者包括医疗保健提供者和两个患者组(一组接受常规护理[CAU],另一组在提供者接受PTH CR培训后接受护理[CR+])。在三个时间点对提供者进行访谈:(1)在CAU入组前;(2)在CAU入组后但培训前;(3)在CR+随访后。来自第二次和第三次提供者访谈的数据用于评估培训前后提供者实践的潜在差异(n = 13)。患者在脑震荡后6个月内入组。在三个时间点评估患者结局(包括神经行为和头痛症状):在72小时内(n = 35)、在入组后1周(n = 34)和在入组后1个月(n = 27)。与培训前>1周相比,提供者报告的大多数后续护理是在培训后初次就诊的72小时内建议的。此外,与培训前相比,提供者报告培训后根据患者症状进行的就诊次数更多。培训后,大多数提供者报告“根据需要”将患者转诊到更高水平的护理,如果不是“非常罕见”的话,而培训前报告转诊的比例为25%。在入组后1周,CR+患者组报告的看医疗提供者的频率高于CAU组。在1个月随访时这种趋势相反,即与CR+组相比,更多的CAU组患者报告看了医疗提供者。到入组后1周,与CAU组相比,CR+组中报告被转诊到任何其他提供者或专科医生的患者更少。未发现提供者培训对患者结局有差异。研究结果表明,关于脑震荡后头痛管理CR的培训是可行的,通过促进及时护理来改变提供者的实践,并通过改善随访就诊和在初级保健诊所进行更多监测来促进患者依从性。