Department of Epidemiology and Psychosocial Research, National Institute of Psychiatry Ramón de la Fuente Muñiz, Mexico City, Mexico.
Population Studies Center, Institute for Social Research, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
JAMA Netw Open. 2020 Nov 2;3(11):e2019848. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.19848.
This study offers a rare opportunity to evaluate life-course differences in the likelihood of developing major depressive disorder (MDD) after exposure to georeferenced neighborhood-level violence during an armed conflict.
To examine age cohort (age <11 vs ≥11 years) differences in associations of neighborhood-level violence with subsequent depression onset, independently of individual exposure and other key characteristics.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: The Chitwan Valley Family Study is a population-representative panel study (1995 to present) conducted in Western Chitwan in Nepal, a low-income country that experienced a medium-intensity armed conflict from 2000 to 2006. Data for violent events were collected during the armed conflict and were linked to lifetime histories of MDD (collected in 2016-2018). The present cohort study analyzes 10 623 participants within 151 neighborhoods, systematically selected and representative of Western Chitwan. All residents aged 15 to 59 years at MDD assessment were eligible (response rate, 93%). Data analysis was performed from May 2019 to July 2020.
Georeferenced number of armed conflict-related physical beatings within 1 km of residential neighborhood.
The main outcome was onset of MDD, as defined by Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (Fourth Edition), during or after the conflict, stratified by children (aged <11 years) and older individuals (aged ≥11 years), assessed by the Nepal-specific World Mental Health-Composite International Diagnostic Instrument 3.0 with a life history calendar.
In total, 10 623 participants (5745 female [54.08%]; 4074 [38.35%] aged <11 years at the conflict start) contributed 171 899 person-years of exposure to the risk of MDD. Two or more beatings occurred within 1 km of 15 neighborhoods (9.9%). Discrete-time survival models showed that children (but not older individuals) living in neighborhoods with 2 or more beatings had a higher likelihood of developing MDD than those who lived in a community with no beatings (odds ratio, 1.82; 95% CI, 1.17-2.84; P = .008); there was also a significant interaction between age group and neighborhood beatings (odds ratio, 1.85; 95% CI, 1.27-2.70; P = .001). A confirmatory, multivariable, multilevel matching analysis showed a neighborhood association for children (z = -2.66; P = .008), but not older individuals (z = -0.454; P = .65). The mean (SE) incidence of MDD among children living in neighborhoods with 2 or more beatings nearby was 12.69% (2.37%) vs 5.08% (1.56%) in the matched unexposed sample.
The youngest individuals may be the most at risk during times of violence, with mental health consequences lasting long after conflicts have subsided and should be a priority for population-level interventions. Future research should consider other disorders, other types of violence, and elderly individuals.
本研究提供了一个难得的机会,可以评估在武装冲突期间接触到地理定位的邻里层面暴力后,在生命历程中出现重度抑郁症(MDD)的可能性方面,不同年龄队列(年龄<11 岁与≥11 岁)的差异。
独立于个体暴露和其他关键特征,检查邻里层面暴力与随后抑郁发作之间的关联,按年龄队列(年龄<11 岁与≥11 岁)进行差异分析。
设计、地点和参与者:Chitwan Valley Family 研究是一项在尼泊尔西部 Chitwan 进行的代表性人群纵向研究(1995 年至今),尼泊尔是一个经历中等强度武装冲突的低收入国家,2000 年至 2006 年发生了武装冲突。在武装冲突期间收集了暴力事件的数据,并将其与 MDD 的终生史(在 2016-2018 年收集)相关联。本队列研究分析了来自 151 个邻里的 10623 名参与者,这些邻里是通过系统选择的,代表了西部 Chitwan。所有在 MDD 评估时年龄在 15 至 59 岁的居民都有资格参加(应答率为 93%)。数据分析于 2019 年 5 月至 2020 年 7 月进行。
居住社区 1 公里范围内与武装冲突有关的身体殴打次数的地理定位。
主要结果是在冲突期间或之后出现 MDD,根据尼泊尔特定的世界心理健康-综合国际诊断工具 3.0 与生活史日历进行定义,按儿童(<11 岁)和年龄较大的个体(≥11 岁)分层,评估为精神障碍诊断与统计手册(第四版)。
共有 10623 名参与者(5745 名女性[54.08%];151 个邻里中有 4074 名[38.35%]在冲突开始时年龄<11 岁)提供了 171899 人年的 MDD 风险暴露。有 15 个邻里发生了 2 次或更多次殴打事件(9.9%)。离散时间生存模型显示,与生活在没有殴打事件的社区的参与者相比,生活在发生 2 次或更多次殴打事件的社区的儿童(但不是年龄较大的个体)更有可能患上 MDD(优势比,1.82;95%置信区间,1.17-2.84;P=0.008);年龄组和邻里殴打之间也存在显著的相互作用(优势比,1.85;95%置信区间,1.27-2.70;P=0.001)。一项确认性、多变量、多层次匹配分析显示,儿童存在邻里关联(z=-2.66;P=0.008),但年龄较大的个体没有关联(z=-0.454;P=0.65)。在有 2 次或更多次附近殴打事件的儿童居住的邻里中,MDD 的平均(SE)发生率为 12.69%(2.37%),而匹配的未暴露样本中为 5.08%(1.56%)。
最年轻的个体在暴力时期可能面临最大的风险,其心理健康后果在冲突结束很久后仍会持续,应成为人群干预的重点。未来的研究应考虑其他疾病、其他类型的暴力和老年个体。