Rodrigues Mendonça Dilton, Villa Nova Aguiar Carolina, Lins-Kusterer Liliane, Lemos Correia Luis Claudio, Martins Tourinho Costa Lysandro, Silva Menezes Marta
Programa de Pós-Graduação em Medicina e Saúde Humana. Escola Bahiana de Medicina e Saúde Pública. Salvador. Bahia. Brasil.
Programa de Pós-Graduação em Medicina e Saúde Humana. Escola Bahiana de Medicina e Saúde Pública. Salvador. Bahia. Brazil.
Acta Med Port. 2021 Feb 1;34(2):95-102. doi: 10.20344/amp.12948. Epub 2020 Nov 17.
The practice of unnecessary conduct and waste in Health is an important topic, not often addressed during undergraduate training. Medical education has a fundamental role in student and doctors' training concerning cost-conscious attitudes for good health care. The aim of this study was to describe and assess the implementation of the Choosing Wisely campaign within a General Surgery residency program.
This was an interventional study involving residency advisors and specialty residents. Recommendations based on three procedures frequently used in clinical practice, with no benefits and involving unnecessary risks for patients were identified by residency advisors with the use of the Delphi method and were grouped by frequency and by nature according to the Choosing Wisely layout. Educational actions such as workshops and banner advertising in addition to training activities regarding cost-conscious healthcare were carried out. This subject was also included in the theoretical evaluation of the residency program.
The leading five recommendations were related to (i) computed tomography overuse (versus ultrasound imaging) in patients with suspected acute appendicitis, (ii) multithreaded computed tomography overuse in patients with low-risk trauma, (iii) longer than recommended antibiotic prophylaxis in surgical patients, (iv) longer than recommended preoperative fasting period and (v) upper gastrointestinal endoscopy overuse in surgical patients without an adequate clinical evidence or without the presence of warning signs. Awareness and reflection among participants were improved, leading to high grades in final evaluation.
Changes in training regarding quality of care and cost awareness should start throughout undergraduate training, within a learning environment focused on a reflective and evidence-based practice. All the benefits and harms to patients were taken into account in the recommendations that emerged from this study.
The inclusion of this initiative in the General Surgery residency, involving reflective discussions on campaign recommendations regarding procedures frequently used in clinical practice, with no benefits and involving unnecessary risks for patients may lead to more cost-conscious procedures.
医疗领域中不必要的行为和浪费现象是一个重要话题,在本科培训期间却很少被提及。医学教育在培养学生和医生注重成本效益的良好医疗态度方面起着基础性作用。本研究的目的是描述和评估“明智选择”运动在普通外科住院医师培训项目中的实施情况。
这是一项涉及住院医师导师和专科住院医师的干预性研究。住院医师导师采用德尔菲法确定了基于临床实践中经常使用的三种无益处且给患者带来不必要风险的手术的建议,并根据“明智选择”的布局按频率和性质进行了分组。开展了诸如研讨会和横幅广告等教育活动,以及关于注重成本效益的医疗保健的培训活动。该主题也纳入了住院医师培训项目的理论评估。
排名前五的建议涉及:(i)疑似急性阑尾炎患者中计算机断层扫描(CT)的过度使用(与超声成像相比);(ii)低风险创伤患者中多排螺旋CT的过度使用;(iii)外科手术患者抗生素预防时间长于推荐时间;(iv)术前禁食时间长于推荐时间;(v)无充分临床证据或无警示体征的外科手术患者中上消化道内镜的过度使用。参与者的意识和反思能力得到了提高,在最终评估中获得了高分。
关于医疗质量和成本意识的培训变革应在本科培训期间就开始,在以反思性和循证实践为重点的学习环境中进行。本研究提出的建议考虑了对患者所有的益处和危害。
将该倡议纳入普通外科住院医师培训,涉及对临床实践中经常使用的无益处且给患者带来不必要风险的手术的运动建议进行反思性讨论,可能会带来更注重成本效益的手术操作。