Hackett G I, Boddie H G, Harrison P
University of Keele, Department of Postgraduate Medicine, North Staffordshire Medical Institute, Stoke-on-Trent.
J R Soc Med. 1987 Nov;80(11):689-91. doi: 10.1177/014107688708001110.
Seventy consecutive patients presenting with a clinical diagnosis of chronic muscle contraction headache over a two-year period were evaluated for depression and anxiety scores, along with other possible aetiological factors in this form of headache. Fifty-five of these patients (33 from a hospital neurology clinic and 22 from a local general practice) completed a double-blind study to evaluate flupenthixol 0.5 mg twice daily, diazepam 5 mg twice daily and placebo as prophylactic agents. Patients evaluated in the hospital neurology clinic had more frequent headaches of longer duration, higher analgesic consumption and higher depression, but no higher anxiety scores than those in general practice. Flupenthixol and diazepam were both significantly superior to placebo in reducing headaches and analgesic consumption. The trend was for flupenthixol to be superior to diazepam without reaching statistical significance. Flupenthixol was significantly better than diazepam and placebo in the reduction of Hamilton depression scores. This effect was independent of the effect on headache and analgesic reduction.
在两年时间里,对70例临床诊断为慢性肌肉收缩性头痛的连续患者进行了抑郁和焦虑评分评估,以及这种形式头痛的其他可能病因因素评估。其中55例患者(33例来自医院神经科门诊,22例来自当地普通诊所)完成了一项双盲研究,以评估每日两次服用0.5毫克氟哌噻吨、每日两次服用5毫克地西泮和安慰剂作为预防药物的效果。在医院神经科门诊接受评估的患者头痛更频繁、持续时间更长、镇痛药消耗量更高且抑郁程度更高,但焦虑评分并不高于普通诊所的患者。氟哌噻吨和地西泮在减少头痛和镇痛药消耗量方面均显著优于安慰剂。趋势是氟哌噻吨优于地西泮,但未达到统计学显著性。在降低汉密尔顿抑郁评分方面,氟哌噻吨显著优于地西泮和安慰剂。这种效果独立于对头痛和镇痛药减少的效果。