University of Rwanda, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, School of Public Health, Kigali, Rwanda.
Schools of Medicine and Public Health, University of Lubumbashi, Lubumbashi, Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Pan Afr Med J. 2020 Sep 14;37:55. doi: 10.11604/pamj.2020.37.55.20376. eCollection 2020.
Universal Health Coverage (UHC) has engaged attention of policy makers at both global and country levels. UHC is one of three strategic priorities of World Health Organization's (WHO) general program of work for 2019-2023, and it is then a global health priority. Rwanda Community-Based Health Insurance is considered the vehicle for UHC and Universal Health Insurance in Rwanda. CBHI was officially introduced in 1999/2000 and through 2011/2012 Rwanda was not far from effective UHC. However, since then, CBHI faced chronic financial deficit. This study aims to assess challenges facing Community-Based Health Insurance financial sustainability and to propose indicative solutions.
quantitative, qualitative, analytical, longitudinal (2011-2018) and documentary mixed methods were applied. One National Pooling Risk (100%), 15 Community-Based Health Insurance districts (50%) and 60 Community Based Health Insurance sections (13.33%) were randomly selected and included in the study. To assess major challenges, "analyzing qualitative data G3658-6 approach" and "prioritization hanlon method" were used.
the study highlighted five major challenges: (i) disproportionate risk-equalization in the social health insurance contributory system; (ii) unit cost exceeding individual income (premium plus other revenues and subsidies); (iii) imperfection in funding mobilization and recovery; (iv) cost-escalation; (v) diseconomy of scale; and the study proposed indicative solutions including injection of additional funding and shifting from current fee-for-service payment to fully active strategic purchasing mechanisms as accompanying measures.
CBHI financial sustainability is achievable, but this is contingent upon persistence of political commitment efforts to achieve UHC, correction of highlighted imperfections and injection of additional funding to allow Rwanda Community-Based Health Insurance to meet and/or exceed its cost in the long-term.
全民健康覆盖(UHC)已引起全球和国家各级决策者的关注。UHC 是世界卫生组织(WHO)2019-2023 年一般工作计划的三个战略重点之一,因此它是一项全球卫生优先事项。卢旺达社区健康保险被认为是卢旺达全民健康覆盖和全民健康保险的手段。CBHI 于 1999/2000 年正式推出,到 2011/2012 年,卢旺达已接近实现全民健康覆盖。然而,从那时起,CBHI 一直面临着长期的财务赤字。本研究旨在评估社区健康保险财务可持续性面临的挑战,并提出指示性解决方案。
采用定量、定性、分析、纵向(2011-2018 年)和文献混合方法。随机选择了一个国家统筹风险(100%)、15 个社区健康保险区(50%)和 60 个社区健康保险区(13.33%)进行研究。为了评估主要挑战,使用了“分析定性数据 G3658-6 方法”和“优先汉隆方法”。
研究强调了五个主要挑战:(i)社会健康保险缴费制度中的风险均衡不成比例;(ii)单位成本超过个人收入(保费加上其他收入和补贴);(iii)资金动员和回收不完善;(iv)成本上升;(v)规模不经济;研究提出了包括注入额外资金和从当前按服务收费支付转向全面积极的战略采购机制等配套措施。
CBHI 的财务可持续性是可以实现的,但这取决于政治承诺努力实现 UHC 的持续存在、纠正突出的缺陷和注入额外资金,以使卢旺达社区健康保险能够在长期内满足和/或超过其成本。