Skorodumova E G, Kostenko V A, Skorodumova E A, Siverina A V, Rysev A V, Gayvoronskiy I V, Ilina V A, Shulenin K S, Gayvoronskiy I N
St. Petersburg I.I. Dzhanelidze Research Institute of Emergency medicine, St. Petersburg, Russia.
Military medical academy n.a. S.M. Kirov, St. Petersburg, Russia.
Kardiologiia. 2020 Nov 12;60(10):80-85. doi: 10.18087/cardio.2020.10.n923.
Aim To study ultrasonic characteristics of lung tissue in patients with heart failure with left ventricular (LV) mid-range ejection fraction (HFmEF) and predictive value of these characteristics after reversing acute decompensated heart failure (ADHF).Material and methods Ultrasonic characteristics of lung tissue were studied by prospective observation in 71 patients (mean age, 65.2±3.6 years; men, 64.3 %) with HFmEF (LVEF from 40 to 49 %) following ADHF reversal. Semiquantitative evaluation of B-lines was performed by the E. Picano (2016) method at 5+2 days after hospitalization and on discharge from the hospital. The distance between B-lines was 3 mm (В3 lines) and 7 mm (В7 lines). Patients' catamnesis was studied for determining the predictive value of lung tissue ultrasonic characteristics for two years since the index hospitalization. Statistical analysis was performed using the McNemar's χ2 test (for evaluation of linked samples and of changes in the presence/absence of B-lines as determined by lung ultrasound examination (USE)) and the Wilcoxon test (for evaluation of quantitative changes). Differences were considered significant at p<0.05.Results B7-lines characteristic of interstitial component of pulmonary parenchymal edema prevailed in patients with HFmEF. В3-lines characteristic of alveolar edema were found in a small amount. In the anterior-superior segment, B7-lines predominated over B3-lines (80 % vs. 20 %, p<0.01) on the right; however, on the lest, significant differences were not observed (64 % vs. 36 %, p>0.05). In the anterior-inferior segment, В7-lines prevailed over В3-lines on the right (75 % vs. 25 %, p<0.05); however, on the left, the difference was not significant (67 % vs. 33 %, p=0.05). In the lateral superior segment on the right, В7-lines predominated over В3-lines (75 % vs. 25 %, p<0.01); in contrast, on the left, there were no differences (67 % vs. 33 %, p>0.05). In lateral-basal segments on both sides, significant differences were present (73 % vs. 27 % on the right, p<0.05; 72 % vs. 28 % on the lest, p<0.05). The results of lung ultrasound were also used for evaluation of the B-line predictive value in patients with ADHF and mid-range EF on discharge from the hospital after reversal of X-ray and clinical symptoms of pulmonary congestion. In the next two years, 35 patients (49.2 % of sample) were rehospitalized with signs of ADHF (39 hospitalizations, 1.1 hospitalizations per patient). The rehospitalized patients were divided into two subgroups, with an increased number of B-lines and small congestion on discharge (6-15 В-lines) and without signs of congestion (<5 В-lines). For patients with a minimal (small) congestion on pulmonary ultrasound but regression of clinical and X-ray congestion, the number of rehospitalizations was 25 vs. 11 in patients with the number of B7-lines <5. In the ROC-analysis, the area under the curve was 0.706, which corresponded to the expert assessment as "good". The position sensitivity was 78.6 % and the specificity was 79.7 %.Conclusion "Ultrasonic pulmonary edema syndrome" in patients with LV mid-range ejection fraction after reversing ADHF was characterized by predomination of the interstitial component, despite the absence of X-ray congestion, correlated with the blood level of NT-proBNP measured at the same time, and was associated with rehospitalizations.
目的 研究左心室(LV)中度射血分数(HFmEF)心力衰竭患者肺组织的超声特征以及急性失代偿性心力衰竭(ADHF)逆转后这些特征的预测价值。
材料和方法 对71例(平均年龄65.2±3.6岁;男性占64.3%)HFmEF(左心室射血分数40%至49%)且ADHF逆转后的患者进行前瞻性观察,研究肺组织的超声特征。在住院5 + 2天及出院时,采用E. Picano(2016)方法对B线进行半定量评估。B线间距为3 mm(B3线)和7 mm(B7线)。研究患者的病史以确定自索引住院起两年内肺组织超声特征的预测价值。采用McNemar卡方检验(用于评估相关样本以及肺超声检查(USE)确定的B线有无变化)和Wilcoxon检验(用于评估定量变化)进行统计分析。p<0.05时差异被认为具有统计学意义。
结果 HFmEF患者中以肺实质水肿间质成分特征的B7线为主,少量存在以肺泡水肿为特征的B3线。在右上段,右侧B7线多于B3线(80%对20%,p<0.01);然而,左侧未观察到显著差异(64%对36%,p>0.05)。在右下段,右侧B7线多于B3线(75%对25%,p<0.05);但左侧差异不显著(67%对33%,p = 0.05)。在右侧外上段,B7线多于B3线(75%对25%,p<0.01);相比之下,左侧无差异(67%对33%,p>0.05)。在两侧的外侧基底段均存在显著差异(右侧73%对27%,p<0.05;左侧72%对28%,p<0.05)。肺超声结果还用于评估ADHF且中度射血分数患者在X线和肺充血临床症状逆转出院时B线的预测价值。在接下来的两年中,35例患者(样本的49.2%)因ADHF症状再次住院(39次住院,人均1.1次住院)。再次住院的患者分为两个亚组,出院时B线数量增加且有少量充血(6 - 15条B线)和无充血迹象(<5条B线)。对于肺超声有最小(少量)充血但临床和X线充血消退的患者,B7线数量<5条的患者再次住院次数为25次对11次。在ROC分析中,曲线下面积为0.706,对应专家评估为“良好”。定位敏感性为78.6%,特异性为79.7%。
结论 ADHF逆转后LV中度射血分数患者的“超声肺水肿综合征”特征为间质成分占主导,尽管无X线充血,与同期测量的NT - proBNP血水平相关,且与再次住院有关。