Stare Jernej, Gradišek Anton, Seliger Janez
Theory Department, National Institute of Chemistry, Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Phys Chem Chem Phys. 2020 Dec 16;22(47):27681-27689. doi: 10.1039/d0cp04710d.
Systems with short hydrogen bonds (H-bonds) are notoriously difficult to describe even using cutting edge experimental techniques supported by advanced computational protocols. One of the most challenging issues is the highly dislocated H-bonded proton, which is typically smeared over a large area, featuring complex dynamics governed by pronounced nuclear quantum effects. Thus, in combination with experimental results, these systems offer a rich platform for the benchmarking of various computational approaches and methods. Herein, we present a methodology combining experimental and computational assessment of H-bond observables probed by the nuclear quadrupole resonance technique. Focusing on the case of picolinic acid N-oxide featuring one of the shortest known hydrogen bonds (ROO ∼ 2.425 Å), we compare the predictions of nuclear quadrupole coupling constants (NQCCs) for a series of computational models differing in fine structural details of the H-bond. By comparing the computed 14N and 17O NQCCs with the measured ones and by analyzing the sensitivity of NQCCs to H-bond geometry variations, we demonstrate that NQCCs represent a very sensitive probe for H-bond geometry, particularly the proton location, thereby offering, in conjunction with computations, an accurate and reliable tool for the fine structural characterization of short H-bonds. Importantly, the present methodology is a good compromise between accuracy and computational cost.
即使使用先进计算协议支持的前沿实验技术,具有短氢键(H键)的体系也极难描述。最具挑战性的问题之一是高度错位的氢键质子,它通常分布在很大的区域,具有由显著核量子效应控制的复杂动力学。因此,结合实验结果,这些体系为各种计算方法和手段的基准测试提供了丰富的平台。在此,我们提出一种结合核四极共振技术探测的氢键可观测量的实验和计算评估的方法。以具有已知最短氢键之一(ROO ∼ 2.425 Å)的吡啶甲酸N-氧化物为例,我们比较了一系列在氢键精细结构细节上不同的计算模型对核四极耦合常数(NQCCs)的预测。通过将计算得到的14N和17O NQCCs与测量值进行比较,并分析NQCCs对氢键几何结构变化的敏感性,我们证明NQCCs是氢键几何结构,特别是质子位置的非常敏感的探针,从而与计算相结合,为短氢键的精细结构表征提供了一种准确可靠的工具。重要的是,本方法在准确性和计算成本之间取得了良好的平衡。