Division of Hospital Pharmacy Science, Faculty of Pharmacy, Keio University, Shibakoen, Tokyo, Japan;, Email:
Division of Hospital Pharmacy Science, Faculty of Pharmacy, Keio University, Shibakoen, Tokyo, Japan.
Pharmazie. 2020 Nov 1;75(11):548-553. doi: 10.1691/ph.2020.0642.
: To review clinical studies on the nocebo effect. PubMed was searched for relevant clinical studies as well as studies on the relationship between the nocebo effect and genes. : A total of 35 clinical studies on the nocebo effect and one study on its relationship with genes were selected for review. All were conducted outside Japan. : An increasing number of clinical studies on the nocebo effect are being published. The 36 studies selected for review were grouped into the following five categories: (1) studies of how differences in participant characteristics such as personality affect susceptibility to the nocebo effect, (2) studies of how differences in provision of information about side effects affect susceptibility to the nocebo effect, (3) studies of how nocebo conditioning affects susceptibility to the nocebo effect, (4) studies of nocebo response mechanisms, and (5) studies of the nocebo effect and genetic polymorphisms. The first four categories comprised 5, 19, 8, and 3 studies, respectively, and the fifth comprised 1 study. Most of the studies investigated how differences in the provision of information affect susceptibility to the nocebo effect. Few studies investigated individual differences in the nocebo effect (differences between responders and non-responders) or mechanisms of the nocebo effect.
:综述关于非安慰剂效应的临床研究。在 PubMed 上搜索了相关的临床研究以及非安慰剂效应与基因之间关系的研究。:共选择了 35 项关于非安慰剂效应的临床研究和一项关于其与基因关系的研究进行综述。这些研究均在日本以外进行。:关于非安慰剂效应的临床研究越来越多。本次综述共选择了 36 项研究,将其分为以下五类:(1)研究参与者特征(如个性)差异如何影响对非安慰剂效应的易感性,(2)研究关于副作用信息提供方式的差异如何影响对非安慰剂效应的易感性,(3)研究非安慰剂条件作用如何影响对非安慰剂效应的易感性,(4)研究非安慰剂反应机制,(5)研究非安慰剂效应和遗传多态性。前四类分别包含 5、19、8 和 3 项研究,第五类包含 1 项研究。大多数研究调查了信息提供方式的差异如何影响对非安慰剂效应的易感性。很少有研究调查非安慰剂效应的个体差异(反应者和非反应者之间的差异)或非安慰剂效应的机制。