Suppr超能文献

监禁对夫妻关系中暴力行为的影响:将约翰逊的类型学应用于理解暴力的夫妻层面背景。

Types of Partner Violence in Couples Affected by Incarceration: Applying Johnson's Typology to Understand the Couple-level Context for Violence.

机构信息

RTI International, Durham, NC, USA.

Duke University, Durham, NC, USA.

出版信息

J Interpers Violence. 2022 May;37(9-10):NP8056-NP8087. doi: 10.1177/0886260520971266. Epub 2020 Nov 27.

Abstract

In prior research, samples of incarcerated and reentering men and their partners report partner violence at roughly 10 times the frequency found in the general population. The relationship dynamics underlying these experiences remain poorly understood. Addressing this gap and expanding prior applications of Johnson's typology in other populations-which typically rely on survey data alone and include reports from just one member of a couple-we applied latent class analysis with dyadic survey data from 1,112 couples to identify types of partner violence in couples affected by incarceration. We assessed congruence between quantitative types and couples' qualitative accounts and compared the two major types using two-sample -tests.In some couples, one partner used various tactics to systematically dominate and control the other, as in Johnson's coercive controlling violence. In others, physical violence arose in the context of jealousy but no other controlling behavior. This type resembled Johnson's situational couple violence. Qualitative data suggested that jealousy represented a common, situational response to periods of prolonged separation, relationship instability, status insecurity, and partnership concurrence and not a tactic of control per se. Victims of coercive controlling violence experienced more PTSD symptoms and felt less safe in their relationships than victims of jealous-only violence. Perpetrators of coercive controlling violence were more likely to use severe physical violence against their partners than perpetrators of jealous-only violence. Findings indicate that broader context is critical for interpreting the presence of jealousy (and whether it constitutes a control tactic). They indicate that prevention and response strategies tailored to these types could help couples cope safely with the extreme relationship stressors of incarceration and reentry. Finally, they suggest a need to move from an exclusive focus on individual accountability and services toward a model that also incorporates institutional accountability and change.

摘要

在先前的研究中,被监禁和重新进入社会的男性及其伴侣的样本报告称,伴侣暴力的频率大约是普通人群的 10 倍。这些经历背后的关系动态仍未得到很好的理解。为了填补这一空白,并扩展约翰逊分类法在其他人群中的先前应用——这些应用通常仅依赖于调查数据,并且仅包括夫妻中一方的报告——我们应用了潜类分析,对 1112 对夫妇的对偶调查数据进行了分析,以确定受监禁影响的夫妇中伴侣暴力的类型。我们评估了定量类型和夫妻定性描述之间的一致性,并使用两样本检验比较了两种主要类型。在一些夫妇中,一方使用各种策略来系统地支配和控制另一方,就像约翰逊的强制性控制暴力一样。在另一些夫妇中,暴力是在嫉妒的情况下出现的,但没有其他控制行为。这种类型类似于约翰逊的情境夫妻暴力。定性数据表明,嫉妒是对长时间分离、关系不稳定、地位不安全以及伙伴关系一致和不稳定的共同、情境性反应,而不是控制策略本身。强制性控制暴力的受害者比嫉妒暴力的受害者经历更多的创伤后应激障碍症状,感到关系更不安全。强制性控制暴力的施害者比嫉妒暴力的施害者更有可能对其伴侣使用严重的身体暴力。研究结果表明,更广泛的背景对于解释嫉妒的存在(以及它是否构成一种控制策略)至关重要。它们表明,针对这些类型的预防和应对策略可以帮助夫妻安全应对监禁和重新进入带来的极端关系压力。最后,它们表明需要从单纯关注个人责任和服务转向一种还包括机构责任和变革的模式。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验