Zhou Xiaoyun, Li Hongsen, Qiao Qing, Pan Hongming, Fang Yong
Department of Medical Oncology, Sir Run Run Shaw Hospital, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China; Department of Medical Oncology, Sir Run Run Shaw Hospital, Xiasha Campus, Hangzhou, China.
Department of Medical Oncology, Sir Run Run Shaw Hospital, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China.
Ann Palliat Med. 2021 Feb;10(2):1494-1502. doi: 10.21037/apm-19-474. Epub 2020 Nov 24.
Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) is the current gold standard for palliative care of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Pain relief for advanced metastases of NSCLC is notoriously difficult. Combined RFA therapy may be more effective than palliating therapy alone in management of painful metastatic disease. The effects of RFA on quality of life, particularly pain, as well as long-term outcome studies are not well studied. To study the effectiveness of percutaneous minimal invasive RFA in pain management of NSCLC patients with metastatic chest wall, vertebral bodies and rib, and periphery lung nodule.
Forty patients with 59 tumors underwent percutaneous computed tomography (CT) or ultrasound-guided RFA for pain management over a 4-week observation. Forty patients were referred to ablation because of persistent severe pain despite using analgesics, chemotherapy or radiotherapy. The tumors were located in the periphery lung, or metastatic to chest wall, rib or vertebral body. Quantitative pain scale values were quantified on a 0-10 scale before, 24 hours, 72 hours, and 4 weeks after RFA. On the basis of changes in pain score and pain medication use, pain was reported with a composite measure as complete, partial, or no pain response. The overall survival (OS) rate was also collected and calculated with Kaplan-Meier method.
After 4-week follow-up, complete pain relief (pain scale score ≤1) was observed in 12 patients (30%) and partial pain relief (pain scale score ≤3) in 15 (37.5%) patients; pain relief did not occur in 13 patients (32.5%). There was a significant decrease in pain at 24-hour, 72-hour, and 4-week follow-up compared with pain level at baseline (P<0.01). Opiate use was decreased in 92.5% (37/40) patients, remained unchanged in 7.5% (3/40) at 4 weeks follow-up. There are minor adverse events caused by RFA therapy, including pleural effusion (5/40), post procedural infections (3/40), pneumothorax (2/40) which resolved spontaneously. The OS rates at 6 months in the percutaneous RFA group were 60%, with average OS of 6.5 months in the further follow-up.
Percutaneous RFA resulted in sustained pain relief from in most advanced NSCLC patients with intractable pain and resistant to chemotherapy or radiotherapy. The effect of RFA was satisfactory, and patients can obtain a better life quality with less pain and complications.
射频消融(RFA)是目前非小细胞肺癌(NSCLC)姑息治疗的金标准。NSCLC晚期转移导致的疼痛缓解 notoriously difficult(此短语有误,应是“极其困难”)。联合RFA治疗在处理疼痛性转移性疾病方面可能比单纯姑息治疗更有效。RFA对生活质量的影响,尤其是疼痛,以及长期疗效研究尚未得到充分研究。本研究旨在探讨经皮微创RFA在治疗NSCLC合并胸壁、椎体、肋骨及外周肺结节转移患者疼痛方面的有效性。
40例患者共59个肿瘤接受了经皮计算机断层扫描(CT)或超声引导下的RFA治疗,观察期为4周。40例患者因尽管使用了镇痛药、化疗或放疗仍持续存在严重疼痛而接受消融治疗。肿瘤位于外周肺,或转移至胸壁、肋骨或椎体。在RFA治疗前、治疗后24小时、72小时和4周,采用0 - 10分的定量疼痛量表对疼痛程度进行量化。根据疼痛评分和止痛药物使用情况的变化,将疼痛反应综合报告为完全缓解、部分缓解或无缓解。同时收集总体生存率(OS),并采用Kaplan-Meier法进行计算。
4周随访后,12例患者(30%)疼痛完全缓解(疼痛量表评分≤1),15例患者(37.5%)部分缓解(疼痛量表评分≤3);13例患者(32.5%)疼痛未缓解。与基线时的疼痛水平相比,24小时、72小时和4周随访时疼痛均有显著减轻(P<0.01)。4周随访时,92.5%(37/40)的患者阿片类药物使用减少,7.5%(3/40)的患者保持不变。RFA治疗引起的轻微不良事件包括胸腔积液(5/40)、术后感染(3/40)、气胸(2/40),均自行缓解。经皮RFA组6个月时的OS率为60%,进一步随访的平均OS为6.5个月。
经皮RFA能使大多数晚期NSCLC顽固性疼痛且对化疗或放疗耐药的患者持续缓解疼痛。RFA效果满意,患者可获得更好的生活质量,疼痛和并发症更少。