Department of Neurosurgery, Great Ormond Street Hospital, London, UK.
Developmental Imaging and Biophysics Section, UCL GOS Institute of Child Health, London, UK.
Br J Neurosurg. 2021 Aug;35(4):424-429. doi: 10.1080/02688697.2020.1849542. Epub 2020 Dec 14.
Tractography derived from diffusion MRI can provide important insights into human brain microstructure . Neurosurgeons were quick to adopt the technique at the turn of the century, but it remains plagued by technical fallibilities. This study aims to describe how tractography is deployed clinically in a modern-day, public healthcare system, serving as a snapshot from the 'shop floor' of British neurosurgical practice.
An 11-question survey was circulated to the mailing lists of the Society of British Neurological Surgeons and British Neurosurgical Trainees' Association, including questions on frequency, indication, tracts reconstructed, specific details of techniques used and personnel by whom it was performed, and a free-text section on the limitations of tractography.
58 survey responses were received, covering all 40 neurosurgical units in the UK and Ireland. Overall, responses were received from neurosurgeons at 36 units (90.0%) stating tractography was in use at that unit. 74.1% of the responses were from Consultants. The most common indication for tractography was in tumour resection. It was most commonly performed by neuroradiologists or imaging scientists. 75.9% of respondents stated that the model used to process tractography was the diffusion tensor (DTI). Many respondents were unaware of which algorithm (74.1%) or software tools (65.6%) were used by the operator to produce tractography visualisations. The corticospinal tract was the most commonly reconstructed tract. The most commonly cited limitations of the technique were perceived inaccuracy and brain shift.
In this UK-based survey of practising neurosurgeons, we show that 90% of neurosurgical units in the UK and Ireland use tractography regularly; that predominantly DTI-based reconstructions are used; that tumour resection remains the most frequent use of the technique; and that large tracts such as the corticospinal tract are most frequently identified. Many neurosurgeons remain unfamiliar with the underlying methods used to produce tractography visualisations.
基于弥散磁共振成像的束流追踪技术可以为人类大脑微观结构提供重要的见解。神经外科医生在世纪之交迅速采用了这项技术,但它仍然存在技术缺陷。本研究旨在描述在现代公共医疗体系中,束流追踪技术是如何在临床中应用的,它是英国神经外科实践“现场”的一个快照。
向英国神经外科学会和英国神经外科住院医师协会的邮件列表发送了一份 11 个问题的调查问卷,其中包括频率、适应症、重建的束流、使用的特定技术细节以及执行人员,以及关于束流追踪技术局限性的自由文本部分。
共收到 58 份调查回复,涵盖了英国和爱尔兰的所有 40 个神经外科单位。总体而言,36 个单位(90.0%)的神经外科医生回复称该单位正在使用束流追踪技术。74.1%的回复来自顾问。束流追踪技术最常见的适应症是肿瘤切除。它最常由神经放射科医生或影像科学家进行。75.9%的受访者表示,用于处理束流追踪技术的模型是扩散张量成像(DTI)。许多受访者不知道操作人员使用的是哪种算法(74.1%)或软件工具(65.6%)来生成束流追踪可视化图像。皮质脊髓束是最常重建的束流。该技术最常被引用的局限性是感知不准确和脑移位。
在这项针对英国神经外科医生的调查中,我们表明,英国和爱尔兰的 90%的神经外科单位经常使用束流追踪技术;主要使用基于 DTI 的重建技术;肿瘤切除仍然是该技术最常见的应用;并且经常识别到较大的束流,如皮质脊髓束。许多神经外科医生仍然不熟悉生成束流追踪可视化图像所使用的基本方法。