Bhaskar Nitu, Sulyaeva Veronica, Gatapova Elizaveta, Kaichev Vasilii, Rogilo Dmitry, Khomyakov Maxim, Kosinova Marina, Basu Bikramjit
Materials Research Center, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, Karnataka 560012, India.
Nikolaev Institute of Inorganic Chemistry SB RAS, 3, Acad. Lavrentiev Avenue, Novosibirsk 630090, Russia.
ACS Biomater Sci Eng. 2020 Oct 12;6(10):5571-5587. doi: 10.1021/acsbiomaterials.0c00472. Epub 2020 Sep 21.
For biomedical applications, a number of ceramic coatings have been investigated, but the interactions with the components of living system remain unexplored for oxycarbonitride coatings. While addressing this aspect, the present study aims to provide an understanding of the biocompatibility of novel SiCNO coatings that could validate the hypothesis that such coatings may not only enhance the cell-material interaction by re-endothelialization but also can help to reduce bacterial adhesion and activation of blood cells. This work reports the physicochemical properties, hemocompatibility, endothelialization, and antibacterial properties of novel amorphous SiCNO coatings deposited on commercial pure titanium (Ti) by radiofrequency (RF) magnetron sputtering at varied nitrogen (N) flow rates. A comparison is made with diamond-like carbon (DLC) coatings, which are clinically used. The surface roughness, surface wettability, nanoscale hardness, and surface energy of SiCNO coatings were found to be dependent on the nitrogen (N) flow rate. Importantly, the as-deposited SiCNO coatings exhibited much better nanoscale hardness and scratch resistance than DLC coatings. Furthermore, Raman spectroscopy analysis of the SiCNO coating deposited on Ti showed a change in the graphitic/disordered carbon content. Cytocompatibility and hemocompatibility properties of the as-deposited SiCNO coating were evaluated using the lymphoid endothelial cell line (SVEC4-10) and rabbit blood . WST-1 assay analysis showed that these coatings, when compared to DLC, exhibited a better proliferation of endothelial cells, which can potentially result in improved surface endothelialization. Furthermore, qualitative and quantitative analyses of immunofluorescence images revealed a dense cellular layer of SVEC4-10 on SiCNO coatings, deposited at 15 and 30 sccm nitrogen flow rates. As far as compatibility with rabbit blood is concerned, the hemolysis of the SiCNO coatings was less than 4%, with slightly lower values for coatings deposited without N flow. The SiCNO coatings support less platelet adhesion and aggregation, with no signature of morphological deformation, as compared to the uncoated titanium substrate or DLC coatings. Furthermore, SiCNO coatings were also found to be effectively extending the blood coagulation time for a period of 60 min. The antimicrobial study of as-deposited SiCNO coatings on and bacteria revealed the effective inhibition of bacterial proliferation after 24 h of culture. An attempt has been made to explain the cyto- and hemocompatibility properties with antimicrobial efficacy of coatings in terms of the variation in the coating composition and surface energy. Taken together, we conclude that SiCNO coating having a roughness of 17 nm and a surface free energy of 54.0 ± 0.7 mN/m can exhibit the best combination of hardness, elastic modulus, scratch resistance, cytocompatibility, hemocompatibility, and bactericidal properties.
对于生物医学应用,人们已经研究了多种陶瓷涂层,但氧碳氮化物涂层与生物系统各成分之间的相互作用仍未得到探索。在解决这一问题时,本研究旨在深入了解新型SiCNO涂层的生物相容性,以验证这样一个假设:此类涂层不仅可以通过再内皮化增强细胞与材料的相互作用,还能有助于减少细菌黏附以及血细胞的激活。本文报道了通过射频(RF)磁控溅射在不同氮气(N)流量下沉积在商业纯钛(Ti)上的新型非晶SiCNO涂层的物理化学性质、血液相容性、内皮化和抗菌性能。并与临床使用的类金刚石碳(DLC)涂层进行了比较。发现SiCNO涂层的表面粗糙度、表面润湿性、纳米硬度和表面能取决于氮气(N)流量。重要的是,沉积态的SiCNO涂层比DLC涂层表现出更好的纳米硬度和耐刮性。此外,对沉积在Ti上的SiCNO涂层的拉曼光谱分析表明,石墨/无序碳含量发生了变化。使用淋巴内皮细胞系(SVEC4-10)和兔血评估了沉积态SiCNO涂层的细胞相容性和血液相容性。WST-1分析表明,与DLC相比,这些涂层能使内皮细胞更好地增殖,这可能会改善表面内皮化。此外,免疫荧光图像的定性和定量分析显示,在15和30 sccm氮气流量下沉积的SiCNO涂层上有一层致密的SVEC4-10细胞层。就与兔血的相容性而言,SiCNO涂层的溶血率小于4%,在无氮气流量下沉积的涂层溶血率略低。与未涂层的钛基材或DLC涂层相比,SiCNO涂层支持更少的血小板黏附和聚集,且没有形态变形的迹象。此外,还发现SiCNO涂层能有效延长血液凝固时间60分钟。对沉积态SiCNO涂层对金黄色葡萄球菌和大肠杆菌的抗菌研究表明,培养24小时后细菌增殖受到有效抑制。本文试图根据涂层成分和表面能的变化来解释涂层的细胞和血液相容性以及抗菌效果。综上所述,我们得出结论,粗糙度为17 nm、表面自由能为54.0±0.7 mN/m的SiCNO涂层在硬度、弹性模量、耐刮性、细胞相容性、血液相容性和杀菌性能方面表现出最佳组合。