School of Psychology, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
PLoS One. 2020 Dec 16;15(12):e0243226. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0243226. eCollection 2020.
Body-worn video is increasingly relied upon in the criminal justice system, however it is unclear how viewing chest-mounted video may affect a police officer's statement about an event. In the present study, we asked whether reviewing footage from an experienced event could shape an individual's statement, and if so, whether reporting before reviewing may preserve an officer's original experience. Student participants (n = 97) were equipped with chest-mounted cameras as they viewed a simulated theft in virtual reality. One week later, half of the participants recalled the event in an initial statement while the other half did not. Participants then viewed either their body-worn video or a control video. Finally, participants provided their statement (no initial statement condition) or were given the opportunity to amend their original account (initial statement condition). Results revealed that viewing body-worn video enhanced the completeness and accuracy of individuals' free recall statements. However, whilst reviewing footage enabled individuals to exclude errors they had written in their initial statements, they also excluded true details that were uncorroborated by the camera footage (i.e., details which individuals experienced, but that their camera did not record). Such camera conformity is discussed in light of the debate on when an officer should access their body-worn video during an investigation and the influence of post-event information on memory.
可穿戴式摄像机在刑事司法系统中的应用日益增多,然而,观看胸戴式摄像机的视频内容会如何影响警察对事件的陈述还不清楚。在本研究中,我们探讨了观看有经验的事件的录像是否会影响个人的陈述,如果是这样,那么在观看录像之前进行汇报是否可以保留警察的原始体验。97 名学生参与者在虚拟现实中观看模拟盗窃事件时配备了胸戴式摄像机。一周后,一半的参与者在初始陈述中回忆了该事件,而另一半则没有。然后,参与者观看了自己的随身摄像机视频或控制视频。最后,参与者提供了他们的陈述(没有初始陈述条件)或有机会修改他们的原始陈述(初始陈述条件)。结果表明,观看随身摄像机视频增强了个人自由回忆陈述的完整性和准确性。然而,虽然观看录像可以让个人排除他们在初始陈述中写入的错误,但他们也排除了没有摄像机录像佐证的真实细节(即个人经历过,但摄像机没有记录的细节)。这种摄像机一致性是在讨论警察在调查期间何时应查看随身摄像机以及事后信息对记忆的影响的背景下进行讨论的。