Department of Radiation Oncology, Sapporo High functioning Radiation Therapy Center, Nishi-ku Miyanosawa 2-jo 1-chome 16-1, Sapporo City, Hokkaido 063-0052, Japan.
Department of Radiation Physics and Technology, Southern Tohoku Proton Therapy Center, Koriyama, Japan.
J Radiat Res. 2021 Mar 10;62(2):186-197. doi: 10.1093/jrr/rraa118.
We used the method proposed by Schneider et al. Theor Biol Med Model 2011;8:27, to clarify how the radiation-induced secondary cancer incidence rate changes in patients after proton craniospinal irradiation (CSI) without and with vertebral-body-sparing (VBS). Eight patients aged 3-15 years who underwent proton CSI were enrolled in the study. For each case, two types of plan without and with VBS in the target were compared. The prescribed doses were assumed to be 23.4 Gy relative biological effectiveness (RBE) and 36 Gy (RBE). Using the dose-volume histograms of the two plans, the lifetime attributable risk (LAR) was calculated by both methods for each patient based on the dose data calculated using an XiO-M treatment planning system. Eight organs were analyzed as follows: lung, colon, stomach, small intestine, liver, bladder, thyroid and bone. When the prescribed dose used was 23.4 Gy (RBE), the average LAR differences and the average number needed to treat (NNT) between proton CSI without and with VBS were 4.04 and 24.8, respectively, whereas the average LAR difference and the average NNT were larger at 8.65 and 11.6, respectively, when the prescribed dose of 36 Gy (RBE) was used. The LAR for radiation-induced secondary cancer was significantly lower in proton CSI with VBS than without VBS in pediatric patients, especially for the colon, lung, stomach and thyroid. The results of this study could serve as reference data when considering how much of vertebral bodies should be included when performing proton CSI according to age in clinical settings.
我们采用了 Schneider 等人提出的方法。Theor Biol Med Model 2011;8:27,旨在阐明质子颅脊照射(CSI)后患者在不进行和进行椎体 spared(VBS)的情况下,辐射诱导继发性癌症发生率如何变化。研究纳入了 8 名年龄在 3-15 岁之间接受质子 CSI 的患者。对于每个病例,比较了目标中没有和有 VBS 的两种计划。假设处方剂量为 23.4 Gy 相对生物效应(RBE)和 36 Gy(RBE)。使用两种计划的剂量体积直方图,根据 XiO-M 治疗计划系统计算的剂量数据,通过两种方法为每位患者计算了终生归因风险(LAR)。分析了以下 8 个器官:肺、结肠、胃、小肠、肝、膀胱、甲状腺和骨骼。当使用 23.4 Gy(RBE)的处方剂量时,质子 CSI 无 VBS 和有 VBS 的平均 LAR 差异和平均需要治疗的人数(NNT)分别为 4.04 和 24.8,而当使用 36 Gy(RBE)的处方剂量时,平均 LAR 差异和平均 NNT 分别为 8.65 和 11.6,分别更大。在儿科患者中,质子 CSI 联合 VBS 的辐射诱导继发性癌症的 LAR 明显低于无 VBS,尤其是对于结肠、肺、胃和甲状腺。当根据年龄在临床实践中进行质子 CSI 时,本研究的结果可作为考虑应包含多少椎体的参考数据。