J Am Dent Assoc. 2021 Feb;152(2):94-104.e18. doi: 10.1016/j.adaj.2020.09.020. Epub 2020 Dec 24.
Variation in opioid prescribing rates among geographic regions is well known and, to the authors' knowledge, there have been no studies of variation from 1 dental clinic to another, and such variation might suggest an excess of opioid prescriptions.
The authors used a retrospective cohort design study of all dental encounter records for 819,453 soldiers in the dental clinics (n = 250) of the US Military Health System during the period from 2008 through 2017.
There were 743,459 dental surgical encounters. Opioid prescriptions were filled for 36.7% of these encounters. Multinomial multilevel regression found statistically significant between-facility variance in opioid prescribing, which was partially explained via facility-level characteristics (region, type, and percentage of surgeries for young patients), and practice variables (mean percentage extractions, percentage periodontic surgery, and percentage specialists).
The authors found a substantial variation in opioid prescribing among dental clinics in the US Military Health System. Dentists at 11 of the 30 largest military treatment facilities prescribed at a rate 4 percentage points higher than expected, and dentists at 9 of these military treatment facilities had a rate of 4 percentage points lower than expected. Additional study of the factors allowing the low-prescribing facilities to achieve these rates might lead to an overall decrease in opioid prescribing.
The authors' findings of dental opioid prescribing in the military can lead to appreciation of the guidelines from the American Dental Association and the American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons, which suggest alternatives to opioid prescribing for surgical procedures, particularly for tooth extractions.
地理区域之间阿片类药物处方率的差异是众所周知的,据作者所知,还没有研究过从一个牙科诊所到另一个牙科诊所的差异,这种差异可能表明阿片类药物处方过多。
作者使用回顾性队列设计研究了 2008 年至 2017 年间美国军事医疗系统 819453 名士兵的所有牙科就诊记录(n=250)。
共有 743459 例牙科手术就诊。这些就诊中有 36.7%的人开了阿片类药物处方。多项分类多层回归发现,阿片类药物处方的机构间差异具有统计学意义,这部分可以通过机构层面的特征(地区、类型和年轻患者手术的百分比)和实践变量(平均拔牙百分比、牙周手术百分比和专家百分比)来解释。
作者发现美国军事医疗系统中牙科诊所的阿片类药物处方存在很大差异。在 30 家最大的军事治疗机构中的 11 家,牙医的处方率比预期高出 4 个百分点,而在其中 9 家军事治疗机构,牙医的处方率比预期低 4 个百分点。对允许低处方率的设施的因素进行进一步研究,可能会导致阿片类药物处方的总体减少。
作者在军队中发现的牙科阿片类药物处方情况,可以让人们更好地了解美国牙科协会和美国口腔颌面外科学会的指南,这些指南建议在手术治疗中替代阿片类药物处方,特别是对于拔牙。