Dufresne F, Carrier L, Gagnon M, Picard D, Chartrand R, Dumont A
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Hôpital Saint-Luc, Québec, Canada.
J Nucl Med. 1988 Jan;29(1):17-22.
There are several methods for detection of bile in the stomach, but none has proven satisfactory. It appears that the scintigraphic study with quantitation of duodenal-gastric reflux after corrections for the overlap of the stomach by the liver and bowel is more reliable, noninvasive, and physiologic. Fifty-four patients were divided into groups according to their clinical presentation; seven asymptomatic volunteers, 20 patients with duodenal-gastric reflux gastropathy (DRG), 16 patients with recurrent ulcers of the duodenal bulb (RUD), and 11 patients with Moynihan's disease. Each of the 47 dyspeptic patients underwent an endoscopic examination and a scintigraphic study with [99mTc]disofenin for detection and quantitation of duodenal-gastric reflux. Endoscopy revealed the presence of bile in the stomach of 16 out of 20 DRG and four out of 16 RUD, while ten out of 11 patients with Moynihan's disease had clear gastric juice. Most of the DRG cases (15 out of 20) and half of the RUD (eight out of 16) presented reflux greater than 1.5%, while of the 11 Moynhihan, ten presented reflux less than 1.5% and all the asymptomatic volunteer subjects less than 1%. This quantitation method allowed us to perceive clearly the low % of reflux in the "normal asymptomatic" subjects compared with the DRG-type of dyspeptic patients. Among the dyspeptic, the distinction seems more evident between the DRG type and the Moynihan type. Occasionally, the scintigraphic method permits identification of patients with slower gallbladder evacuation (eight out of 47 dyspeptic in our study), adding valuable information for the diagnostic approach to dyspeptic patients.
检测胃内胆汁的方法有多种,但尚无一种方法被证明是令人满意的。经肝脏和肠道对胃的重叠部分进行校正后,采用闪烁扫描法对十二指肠-胃反流进行定量研究似乎更可靠、无创且符合生理情况。54例患者根据临床表现分组;7名无症状志愿者,20例十二指肠-胃反流性胃病(DRG)患者,16例十二指肠球部复发性溃疡(RUD)患者,以及11例莫伊尼汉病患者。47例消化不良患者均接受了内镜检查和用[99mTc]二乙三胺五乙酸进行的闪烁扫描研究,以检测和定量十二指肠-胃反流。内镜检查显示,20例DRG患者中有16例胃内存在胆汁,16例RUD患者中有4例胃内存在胆汁,而11例莫伊尼汉病患者中有10例胃液清晰。大多数DRG病例(20例中的15例)和一半的RUD患者(16例中的8例)反流率大于1.5%,而11例莫伊尼汉病患者中有10例反流率小于1.5%,所有无症状志愿者的反流率均小于1%。这种定量方法使我们能够清楚地认识到,与DRG型消化不良患者相比,“正常无症状”受试者的反流率较低。在消化不良患者中,DRG型和莫伊尼汉型之间的区别似乎更为明显。偶尔,闪烁扫描法可识别出胆囊排空较慢的患者(我们研究中的47例消化不良患者中有8例),为消化不良患者的诊断方法提供了有价值的信息。