S.B. Fernandez is a postdoctoral research fellow, Investigator Development Core, Research Center for Minority Institutions, Florida International University, Miami, Florida; ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6243-9463 .
R.D. Clarke is a postdoctoral research fellow, Community-Based Research Institute, Florida International University, Miami, Florida; ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9606-2510 .
Acad Med. 2021 Apr 1;96(4):576-584. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000003902.
Despite efforts to increase the representation of women in the national scientific workforce, results still lag. While women's representation in health-related sciences has increased substantially, women remain underrepresented in senior leadership roles. This study was conducted to elucidate influences at the individual, interpersonal, organizational, and societal levels that present as barriers to and facilitators for advancement in research careers for women, with the goal of promoting and retaining a more diverse leadership.
The authors conducted individual, 1-hour, in-depth, semistructured interviews with 15 female early stage investigators pursuing careers in health sciences research at a large minority-serving institution in Florida in 2018. Interview guides were designed by using a social ecological framework to understand the influence of multilevel systems. Employing a qualitative approach, drawing from a phenomenological orientation, 2 researchers independently coded transcripts and synthesized codes into broad themes.
Barriers and facilitators were reported at all ecological levels explored. Illustrative quotations reflect the unequal distribution of familial responsibilities that compete with career advancement, family members' lack of understanding of the demands of a research career, the importance of female mentors, perceived differences in the roles and expectations of female and male faculty at institutions, and normative upheld values that influence early career progression.
Achieving pervasive and sustained changes that move toward gender equity in research requires solutions that address multilevel, explicit and implicit influences on women's advancement in science. Suggestions include shifting familial and institutional norms, creating support systems for women with female mentors, and enforcing consistent policies regarding the roles and expectations of faculty. Findings shed light on the influence of gender on career progression by providing context for the experiences of women and underscore the importance of addressing pervasive societal and structural systems that maintain inequities hindering women's progress in the scientific workforce.
尽管已经努力增加女性在国家科学队伍中的代表性,但结果仍然滞后。虽然女性在与健康相关的科学领域的代表性大幅增加,但在高级领导职位中仍代表性不足。本研究旨在阐明个体、人际、组织和社会各级对女性在研究职业中晋升的障碍和促进因素的影响,以促进和保留更多元化的领导层。
作者于 2018 年在佛罗里达州的一所大型少数民族服务机构中,对 15 名从事健康科学研究的早期女性研究员进行了个体、1 小时、深入、半结构化的访谈。访谈指南是使用社会生态框架设计的,以了解多层次系统的影响。采用定性方法,从现象学取向出发,2 名研究人员独立对转录本进行编码,并将代码综合成广泛的主题。
在所有探索的生态层次都报告了障碍和促进因素。说明性引语反映了与职业发展竞争的家庭责任的不平等分配、家庭成员对研究职业需求的不理解、女性导师的重要性、机构中女性和男性教职员工角色和期望的差异、以及影响早期职业发展的规范价值观。
要实现研究领域性别平等的普遍和持续变化,需要解决影响女性在科学领域发展的多层次、明确和隐含的影响因素。建议包括改变家庭和机构规范、为有女性导师的女性建立支持系统、以及执行关于教职员工角色和期望的一致政策。研究结果通过为女性的经历提供背景,阐明了性别对职业发展的影响,并强调了解决阻碍女性在科学劳动力中进步的普遍社会和结构性系统的重要性。