Alboliras E T, Seward J B, Hagler D J, Danielson G K, Puga F J, Tajik A J
Section of Pediatric Cardiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905.
Am J Cardiol. 1988 Jan 1;61(1):166-9. doi: 10.1016/0002-9149(88)91324-0.
To determine the impact of 2-dimensional (2-D) and Doppler echocardiography on the care of children aged 2 years and younger with suspected cardiac disease, the clinical management and outcome for the years 1975 (pre-2-D/Doppler era, 161 patients) and 1985 (2-D/Doppler era, 206 patients) were compared. Differences were: (1) decreased catheterization at our institution (48% vs 21%, p less than 0.0001); (2) trend toward decreased recatheterization of patients with referral catheterization (62% vs 38%, p = 0.08); (3) increased operation without preoperative catheterization (10% vs 37%, p less than 0.001); and (4) decreased preoperative catheterization for 7 anomalies (patent ductus arteriosus, ventricular septal defect, atrial septal defect, atrioventricular canal, aortic stenosis, tetralogy of Fallot and complete transposition of great arteries). Operative mortality rates were not statistically different in the years compared. Also, the operative mortality rates in 1985 for patients with and without preoperative catheterization were not statistically different. In 1975, cardiac catheterization changed the primary clinical diagnosis in 21%. In 1985, the primary diagnosis was not changed by catheterization; however, 2-D and Doppler echocardiography changed the diagnosis in 18%. The change in utilization of cardiac catheterization appears to be most closely related to the maximal utilization of a substitute imaging and hemodynamic modality--namely, 2-D and Doppler echocardiography.
为确定二维(2-D)和多普勒超声心动图对2岁及以下疑似心脏病患儿治疗的影响,对1975年(二维/多普勒时代之前,161例患者)和1985年(二维/多普勒时代,206例患者)的临床管理及结果进行了比较。差异如下:(1)我院的心导管插入术减少(48%对21%,p<0.0001);(2)转诊心导管插入术患者再次心导管插入术有减少趋势(62%对38%,p = 0.08);(3)术前未进行心导管插入术的手术增加(10%对37%,p<0.001);以及(4)7种异常(动脉导管未闭、室间隔缺损、房间隔缺损、房室管、主动脉狭窄、法洛四联症和大动脉完全转位)的术前心导管插入术减少。所比较年份的手术死亡率无统计学差异。此外,1985年术前进行和未进行心导管插入术患者的手术死亡率也无统计学差异。1975年,心导管插入术改变了21%的主要临床诊断。1985年,心导管插入术未改变主要诊断;然而,二维和多普勒超声心动图改变了18%的诊断。心导管插入术使用情况的变化似乎与替代成像和血流动力学模式(即二维和多普勒超声心动图)的最大利用最为密切相关。