Schutzer S F, Harris W H
Orthopaedic Research Laboratory, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1988 Feb;227:172-83.
In current practice most primary total hip arthroplasties (THAs) are performed without trochanteric osteotomy. The superior exposure afforded by trochanteric osteotomy, however, can be valuable in revision total hip surgery. Between 1969 and 1983, 188 revisions in 177 patients were carried out with osteotomy of the greater trochanter. Ninety-one percent were reattached with a three- or four-wire method. Sixty-one percent of the trochanters (N = 114) were advanced to the lateral cortex. Supplemental trochanteric mesh was used in 75% of the revisions (141 hips). Its use is now routine for all revisions. Most patients (N = 137) were permitted to ambulate within five days, using a walker or two crutches, bearing partial weight on the operative hip. Ninety-seven percent (182 of 188) of the trochanters united. Six failed to unite (3%) and eight others had delayed healing (4%). Two trochanters migrated proximally prior to union (1%). Retrospective evaluation of the initial postoperative radiographs for each patient with nonunion identified one or more technical errors in the reattachment technique. While the overall incidence of wire breakage was 27%, most (42 of 51) of these trochanters healed uneventfully. Five of the six patients with trochanteric nonunion, however, had failure of one or both vertical wires by 12 weeks after surgery. The average hip score for the patients with nonunion was 89 points (versus 57 points before surgery), indicating that the average clinical outcome in this group was not substantially comprised by trochanteric complications. In light of the improvement in surgical exposure, high rate of union of the trochanter, and limited number of complications, trochanteric osteotomy is recommended for most revision THA.
在目前的临床实践中,大多数初次全髋关节置换术(THA)并不进行转子截骨。然而,转子截骨所提供的更好的显露在髋关节翻修手术中可能很有价值。1969年至1983年间,对177例患者进行了188次大转子截骨翻修手术。91%的患者采用三线或四线法重新固定。61%的转子(n = 114)被推进至外侧皮质。75%的翻修手术(141髋)使用了转子补充网片。目前其使用已成为所有翻修手术的常规操作。大多数患者(n = 137)在术后五天内被允许使用助行器或双拐行走,术侧髋关节部分负重。97%(188例中的182例)的转子愈合。6例未愈合(3%),另有8例愈合延迟(4%)。2例转子在愈合前向近端移位(1%)。对每例不愈合患者术后初期X线片的回顾性评估发现,重新固定技术存在一个或多个技术错误。虽然钢丝断裂的总体发生率为27%,但其中大多数(51例中的42例)转子顺利愈合。然而,6例转子不愈合患者中有5例在术后12周时一根或两根垂直钢丝断裂。不愈合患者的平均髋关节评分为89分(术前为57分),表明该组患者的平均临床结果并未因转子并发症而受到实质性影响。鉴于手术显露的改善、转子的高愈合率以及并发症数量有限,大多数髋关节翻修手术建议进行转子截骨。