Is lymph node dissection for neuroendocrine carcinoma of the stomach effective as it is for adenocarcinoma?

BACKGROUND

We evaluated the significance of lymph node dissection for gastric neuroendocrine carcinoma (NEC) by calculating the therapeutic value index for each station.

METHODS

This study included 2164 advanced gastric cancer patients (common-type [Common-GC], n = 2125; and gastric NEC [NEC-GC], n = 39). Clinicopathological data were collected, and survival, type of recurrence, and the index for each type of gastrectomy were determined.

RESULTS

NEC-GC was characterized by an older population (P = 0.009), upper tumor location (P = 0.021), frequent venous invasion (P < 0.001), and less neural invasion (P = 0.043). NEC-GC tended to be more frequent in men (P = 0.152), and to be associated with total gastrectomy (P = 0.177) and M1 cases (P = 0.167). The five-year overall survival rates of the Common-GC and NEC-GC groups were 73.8% (95% confidence interval: 71.8-75.6) and 54.7% (37.5-68.9), respectively (P = 0.016). Both groups showed similar index values in each station. Regarding the index of the peri-gastric nodal station (D1 station)/stations away from the stomach (D2 station), although the index of the D1 station was similar in the two groups (41.3 and 43.1), the index of the D2 station in the NEC-GC group was approximately half that of the Common-GC group (10.0 and 5.3). The total recurrence rates of the two groups were similar (P = 0.871). However, the rates of hematogenous and lymphatic recurrence tended to be higher in the NEC-GC group (P = 0.132 and P = 0.152).

CONCLUSIONS

The therapeutic efficacy of the D1 station was similar in Common-GC and NEC-GC but that of the D2 station was worse in NEC-GC. Gastrectomy with D2 dissection would be less effective for NEC-GC.