Tseng Chi-Fang, PettyJohn Morgan E, Huerta Patricia, Miller Debra L, Agundez Juan Carlos, Fang Meng, Wittenborn Andrea K
Human Development and Family Studies, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, USA.
Psychiatry and Behavioral Medicine, Michigan State University, Grand Rapids, MI, USA.
Fam Process. 2021 Jun;60(2):424-440. doi: 10.1111/famp.12628. Epub 2021 Jan 12.
Disparities in mental health care among marginalized populations have been well-documented. Without research designed to study interventions for diverse populations, disparities in the quality of services will persist. A systematic review of articles evaluating couple and family therapy (CFT) interventions was conducted to evaluate the representation of diverse populations. More specifically, researchers sought to examine race/ethnicity, sexual orientation, income level, and age of sample participants. One hundred ninety-six studies evaluating CFT interventions in the United States in ten journals were included in the analysis. Findings indicate that family therapy research is more representative of racial minority and low-income participants compared with studies of couple interventions. Couple therapy research is often still conducted with predominately white, middle- to high-income samples. Following whites, African Americans and Hispanic/Latinos were the most common racial/ethnic groups included in both couple therapy research and family therapy research. Participants in same-sex relationships were absent from family intervention research and under-researched in couple intervention studies. Only one couple therapy study recruited a sample in which the average age was late adulthood. These findings are cause for concern given the widening mental health disparities in the United States.
边缘化人群在心理健康护理方面的差异已有充分记录。如果没有旨在研究针对不同人群干预措施的研究,服务质量的差异将持续存在。为了评估不同人群的代表性,对评估夫妻和家庭治疗(CFT)干预措施的文章进行了系统综述。更具体地说,研究人员试图考察样本参与者的种族/民族、性取向、收入水平和年龄。分析纳入了在十种期刊上发表的196项评估美国CFT干预措施的研究。研究结果表明,与夫妻干预研究相比,家庭治疗研究在种族少数群体和低收入参与者中更具代表性。夫妻治疗研究通常仍主要以白人、中高收入样本进行。在白人之后,非裔美国人和西班牙裔/拉丁裔是夫妻治疗研究和家庭治疗研究中最常见的种族/民族群体。同性关系参与者在家庭干预研究中缺失,在夫妻干预研究中的研究也不足。只有一项夫妻治疗研究招募了平均年龄为成年晚期的样本。鉴于美国心理健康差距不断扩大,这些发现令人担忧。